The email prompt formula: four parts
Write the prompt the way you'd brief a new hire: who you are, what to write, an example, and the facts. OpenAI's prompting guide builds a prompt from the same four parts: identity, instructions, examples and context. On context it says:
"Give the model any additional information it might need to generate a response, like private/proprietary data outside its training data, or any other data you know will be particularly relevant." (OpenAI API docs: Prompt engineering)
Your prices, service area and this month's offer are that kind of information. ChatGPT can't know them, so leave nothing for it to guess.
| Part | What to put in | Example: a heating company |
|---|---|---|
| Who you are | Business, town, how you sound | "You write emails for Northside Heating, a family HVAC company in Columbus. Plain, friendly, no hype." |
| The job | Who reads it, the one action, length, what never to do | "Write a 120-word email asking past customers to book a fall furnace tune-up. One link. Don't add facts I didn't give you." |
| An example | A past email that got replies | "Here's an email our customers answered: [paste]. Match its tone." |
| The facts | Offer, price, dates, conditions, link, sign-off | "Tune-up $129 USD, one furnace, book by October 31. Link: [booking link]. Sign as Dana, owner." |
Ask for choices, not one draft: "Give me 5 subject lines and 2 versions of the body." Then steer in plain words: "shorter", "warmer", "cut the second paragraph".
Keep a one-page fact sheet (services, prices, area, hours, guarantee, phone, sign-off) and paste it at the top of every new chat.
ChatGPT prompts for email subject lines
Ask for several, each tied to what's inside. In the US that match is the law:
"Don't use deceptive subject lines. The subject line must accurately reflect the content of the message." (FTC: CAN-SPAM Act compliance guide)
Canada's Competition Act makes a false or misleading subject line on a promotional electronic message reviewable conduct, the same as a misleading sender name (section 74.011(1)).
Prompt: "Here's my email: [paste]. Write 8 subject lines for it, each with a preview line (the short text inboxes show after the subject). Use different styles: a plain statement, a question, the deadline, a number from the email. Every one must describe what's inside. No all caps, no fake 'Re:' or 'Fwd:', no urgency the email doesn't have."
Shortlist two, then test them if your email tool can. Mailchimp, for example, can test the "subject line, From name, content, or send time" with up to 3 versions, and picks a winner by "highest open or click rate, or total revenue" (Mailchimp Help: About A/B tests). Choose clicks. Apple's Mail Privacy Protection "prevents senders from seeing if you've opened the email message they sent you" (Apple Support), so open counts mislead. On a small list, skip the test and count replies and bookings.
ChatGPT prompts for an offer email
Give the exact offer and every condition, and tell ChatGPT to ask rather than fill a gap. The email is your ad, and the FTC's rule for ads is that "Advertisers must have evidence to back up their claims" (FTC: Advertising FAQ's). Cut any "best in town" or "save 30%" you can't prove.
Prompt: "Write an offer email for [business]. Offer: [what], [price and currency], for [who qualifies], valid [start] to [end]. Conditions: [list]. Use only these facts; if something is missing, ask me. Order: the problem the reader has right now, the offer, how to book. Put every condition in the same paragraph as the price. One button: [button text]. Under 150 words."
Some offer words carry their own rules:
| If the email says | The rule |
|---|---|
| "Free" (US) | Conditions "should be set forth clearly and conspicuously at the outset of the offer", and an asterisk pointing to a footnote "is not regarded as making disclosure at the outset" (FTC Guide on "Free", 16 CFR 251.1(c)) |
| A price (Canada) | A price "not attainable due to fixed obligatory charges or fees" counts as misleading, unless the extra is a government-imposed charge such as tax (Competition Act s. 74.011(3.1)) |
| A deadline (Canada) | "Be truthful about the duration of the sale." Fake urgency in email can break the law (Competition Bureau: Fake urgency cues) |
| A customer quote (US) | A business may not write or create a testimonial that misrepresents that the person exists or used the service, or send one it knew or should have known was fake (16 CFR 465.2) |
The last row matters most with AI. Never ask ChatGPT to "add a testimonial". Paste a real review, word for word, or leave it out.
ChatGPT prompts for follow-up emails
Follow-ups repeat, so one good prompt becomes a template for every customer in that spot.
| Situation | What to give ChatGPT | Goal of the email |
|---|---|---|
| Quote sent, no reply | The job, price, what's included, how long the quote holds | Get a yes, a no, or a question |
| Job finished | What you did, one care tip, your review link | Thanks and a review |
| Lead asked a question, then went quiet | Their question and your answer | One next step |
| Past customer, about a year since the last visit | The last service, what's due now | Book the next visit |
Prompt: "Write 3 short follow-up emails to a customer who got a quote and hasn't replied. Quote: [job], [price], valid until [date]. Email 1: check they got it and offer to answer questions. Email 2: one useful fact about the job, such as what happens if they wait. Email 3: a polite last note that leaves the door open. Under 80 words each, easy to read on a phone. End each with one question they can answer in a word. Use [First name] as a placeholder."
Timing and calls for quotes are in unsold estimates; review requests have their own rules in asking for reviews.
In Canada, a follow-up that sells needs consent. Implied consent covers someone who made "an inquiry or application" in the last six months, or bought from you in the last two years (Canada's Anti-Spam Legislation: the law on consent before sending commercial emails and texts to people in Canada. More s. 10(10)). Every such message must identify you, give contact information and include an unsubscribe mechanism (CASL s. 6(2)). Details: CASL consent.
What not to paste into ChatGPT
Paste your business facts. Leave out your customers.
- Use placeholders. Write [First name] and [address], then let your email tool fill them in.
- Know your plan. OpenAI's pricing page lists "Content is used to train our models" for Free, Go, Plus and Pro, with "Opt-out available". The Business plan lists "No training on your business data by default."
- Health details stay out. Clinics: see Is ChatGPT HIPAA compliant?
Check every AI draft before you send
- Facts: price, dates, phone number, link and service area match your fact sheet.
- Claims: you can prove every promise and number.
- Subject line: it describes what's in the email.
- Nothing invented: no reviews, awards or ratings you didn't supply.
- Your voice: read it aloud; cut any word you'd never say to a customer.
- Footer: in the US, "Your message must include your valid physical postal address" and a working unsubscribe (FTC: CAN-SPAM). In Canada, your name, contact details and unsubscribe (CASL s. 6(2)). Full rules: email and text marketing.
- Test: send it to yourself and open it on a phone.
Example
Illustrative cases. Names and numbers are invented for the example.
A cleaning company's spring offer
The owner pastes her fact sheet and the offer: deep clean $199 USD for homes up to 3 bedrooms, booked by April 30. The draft adds "free fridge cleaning" and "rated 5 stars". Neither came from her facts (her Google rating is 4.8), so she cuts both. She sends "Spring deep clean: $199 until April 30" and judges it by bookings.
A Toronto bookkeeper following up quotes
A café owner asked for pricing in March and got a $400 CAD monthly quote. The bookkeeper uses the 3-email follow-up prompt. All three go out within six months of the inquiry, each with his business name, mailing address, phone number and an unsubscribe link.
FAQ
Why does ChatGPT's email copy sound generic?
It knows only what you tell it about your business. Paste a past email in your voice, your fact sheet, and words you never use.
Can I paste my customer list into ChatGPT to personalize emails?
Don't. Use placeholders and let your email tool merge names in. Free, Go, Plus and Pro plans train on your content unless you opt out.
Do the email rules change when AI writes the copy?
No. You're responsible for what you send. Even when you hire a sender, the FTC says "you can't contract away your legal responsibility."
Different for you?
- What to send past customers, how often, and the US email and text rules: email and text marketing.
- Your customers are in Canada: CASL consent.
- Quotes that didn't close: unsold estimates.
- Review requests by email: asking for reviews.
- Patient emails at a clinic: Is ChatGPT HIPAA compliant?
- You'd rather have follow-ups written and sent for you: Conversion Agent.