Why people don't open your emails
Three things decide it, in this order: the email reaches the inbox, the reader still wants mail from you, and the From name, subject line and preview text earn a tap. Fix them in that order. A better subject line can't rescue an email that lands in spam.
| Cause | Signs | Fix |
|---|---|---|
| It never reaches the inbox | Low numbers on every send; mail goes out from a free Gmail or Yahoo address | Own domain, authentication, fewer spam reports |
| The list has gone stale | Many bounces; unsubscribes and spam reports after each send | Remove bad addresses; reconfirm or drop people who stopped clicking |
| The inbox view doesn't earn the tap | Few clicks, few complaints | Rewrite the From name, subject line and preview text; test |
What is a good email open rate?
About a third, by the most quoted benchmark, but treat it loosely. Mailchimp measured campaigns sent to 1,000 or more subscribers and found an average open rate of 35.63% across all users, and 31.35% for business and finance (Mailchimp email marketing benchmarks, data as of December 2023). The same page warns that Apple's privacy changes may affect "the accuracy of email open rates".
Here is why. Apple's Mail Privacy Protection "prevents senders from seeing if you've opened the email message they sent you" (Apple Support). An open is counted when a tiny hidden image in the email loads (Mailchimp Help: About open and click rates), and Apple's protection, spam scanners and link previews often load it before a person does. Mailchimp now hides this "bot activity" by default and warns that open and click numbers "will drop significantly" with the filter on (Mailchimp Help: About bot activity).
What that means for you:
- Compare each send with your own past sends, in the same tool, with the same filter setting.
- A jump after you switch tools or settings says nothing about your emails.
- Count what only a person does: clicks, replies, calls and bookings. Mailchimp suggests adding "bounces, unsubscribes, and conversions" to opens and clicks.
Step 1: get into the inbox
Gmail, Yahoo and Outlook publish their rules. They ask you to prove who you are and to send mail people want.
| Mailbox | Applies to | Rule |
|---|---|---|
| Gmail | Every sender | SPF or DKIM; spam rate below 0.1%, and never 0.3% or higher (Gmail Help: Email sender guidelines) |
| Gmail | Over 5,000 messages a day to Gmail | SPF, DKIM and DMARC, plus one-click unsubscribe, processed "within two days" (Gmail Help; Google's October 2023 announcement) |
| Yahoo | Every sender | SPF or DKIM; spam rate below 0.3% (Yahoo Sender Hub) |
| Yahoo | Bulk senders (Yahoo sets no volume number) | SPF and DKIM, DMARC at least p=none, one-click unsubscribe, unsubscribes honored "within 2 days" (Yahoo Sender Hub: best practices and FAQs) |
| Outlook.com, Hotmail, Live | Domains sending over 5,000 emails a day, from May 5, 2025 | SPF and DKIM must pass; DMARC at least p=none, aligned. Microsoft's April 29, 2025 update says failing mail is rejected (Microsoft, April 2025) |
In plain words: SPF and DKIM prove that mail sent in your name really comes from you; DMARC tells mailboxes what to do when it doesn't. Three moves cover most small senders, even at a few hundred emails a month:
- Send from your own domain, like ana@brightplumbing.com. Mailchimp explains that free email domains "often have policies that tell these receiving servers to reject mail that fails DMARC", and recommends switching to an address on a domain you own (Mailchimp Help: Limitations of free email addresses). If the new address has never sent bulk mail, Gmail's guidelines say to start with a small volume to engaged people and increase it slowly.
- Authenticate that domain in your email tool. The tool gives you the records; whoever runs your domain adds them. Microsoft: "Even if you outsource sending, authentication is tied to your domain," and while its rule targets big senders, "all senders benefit".
- Keep spam reports rare. Gmail's target of 0.1% is 1 report per 1,000 emails; its 0.3% limit is 3. Mail only people who expect you, and make unsubscribing easier than clicking "Report spam".
What every marketing email must contain by law (unsubscribe link, postal address) is in email and text marketing.
Step 2: clean your email list
Dead and unwanted addresses drag down every send. Yahoo is blunt about the worst habit:
"Don't purchase mailing lists or subscribe users by having an opt-in checkbox automatically checked on your website." (Yahoo Sender Hub: Sender best practices)
| Task | How often | What the provider says |
|---|---|---|
| Remove addresses that bounce | After every send | "Remove invalid recipients from your list promptly." (Yahoo) |
| Find people who stopped responding | Monthly or quarterly | Remove inactive or invalid addresses "monthly or quarterly" (Microsoft) |
| Ask them once: still want these? | Then drop anyone who doesn't answer | "Consider sending a reconfirmation email to inactive subscribers periodically." (Yahoo) |
Define "inactive" by what people did, not by opens. Apple Mail users with Mail Privacy Protection on can show opens whether they read or not, so a rule like "no opens in 90 days" keeps cold Apple addresses and drops only the rest. Use no click, reply or booking instead. Pick the window to fit your trade: a furnace or tax customer may need you once a year, so 12 months is fairer than 3.
Send each email only to the people it fits: the furnace tune-up offer to customers with a furnace, not the whole list. Fewer uninterested readers means fewer spam reports.
In Canada, consent comes first: Canada's Anti-Spam Legislation: the law on consent before sending commercial emails and texts to people in Canada. More allows a marketing email only if the person "has consented to receiving it, whether the consent is express or implied" (CASL, s. 6(1)); how long each kind lasts is in CASL consent. US law works the other way: CAN-SPAM doesn't ask for consent first, but every marketing email needs a working opt-out, honored within 10 business days (FTC). A confirmation click at sign-up (double opt-in) is required by neither; Yahoo suggests it to keep invalid addresses off the list.
Step 3: write what the inbox shows
Before anyone opens, the inbox shows three things: "your From name, subject line, and preview text" (Mailchimp Help: About preview text).
| Part | Do | Avoid |
|---|---|---|
| From name | The name customers know from the job: "Bright Plumbing" or "Ana at Bright Plumbing", the same every time | A new name each campaign; a no-reply address. Microsoft asks for a From or Reply-To address that "can receive replies" |
| Subject line | Say what's inside: "Furnace tune-up slots for October" | Seasonal slogans; Mailchimp says lines like "Fall into savings" don't "offer a specific hook" (Mailchimp Help: Best practices for email subject lines) |
| Length | "no more than 9 words and 60 characters" (Mailchimp) | Long lines with the point at the end; Mailchimp notes shorter is often better on phones |
| Punctuation and emoji | At most 3 punctuation marks and 1 emoji, per Mailchimp's research | "FREE!!! Book NOW" |
| Preview text | One line that adds a date, price or deadline | Leaving it blank: the inbox then shows the email's first words, often a "View in browser" link (Mailchimp Help: About preview text) |
| Personal touch | A first name or town, if your data is clean; Mailchimp says personalization "is shown to increase open rates for most users" | A broken merge field that prints "Hi ," |
Honest subject lines are the law
A fake "Re:" or "Your invoice" on an offer may win one open and cost trust after that. In the US, the FTC's CAN-SPAM guide says:
"The subject line must accurately reflect the content of the message." (FTC: CAN-SPAM Act, a compliance guide for business)
In Canada, the Competition Act makes it reviewable conduct to send, to promote a business, "a false or misleading representation in the sender information or subject matter information of an electronic message" (Competition Act, s. 74.011(1)). The Act defines subject matter information as the part that sums up the message: in an email, the subject line.
Step 4: test one change, and judge by clicks
An A/B test sends two versions to two random parts of your list, then the better one to everyone else. In Mailchimp it "is included with all paid marketing plans", and the winner can be picked by "open rate, click rate, or total revenue" (Mailchimp Help: Best practices for email subject lines; About A/B tests). Pick click rate, because machine opens make open-based winners unreliable.
On a list of a few hundred, one test is too small to trust: alternate two styles over several sends and compare clicks and replies. Test how often you send, too. Mailchimp's view: "In general, sending more emails negatively impacts the level of engagement per email sent, but it's different for everyone" (Mailchimp Help: About open and click rates). Keep the pace people signed up for: Yahoo warns against suddenly mailing daily to a weekly or monthly list. Watch unsubscribes and spam reports after each send.
Example
Illustrative cases. List sizes and results are invented for the example.
A plumber mailing from a Yahoo address
She sends a monthly email to 1,500 past customers through an email tool, from a free Yahoo address. Clicks are near zero. She moves to ana@brightplumbing.com, adds the three records the tool gives her, and compares clicks on the next three sends with the last three.
A dental clinic with an eight-year-old list
Of 6,000 addresses, 400 bounce on the first send and 15 people report spam: about 0.27% of the 5,600 delivered, near Gmail's 0.3% limit and well past its 0.1% target. The clinic removes the bounces, emails one "still want our news?" note to patients with no click or visit in two years, and drops the 2,500 who don't answer.
An accounting firm testing subject lines
It tests "Our March newsletter" against "Your tax documents checklist for this year" on 400 contacts each. The checklist gets 36 clicks, the newsletter 10. The checklist goes to the other 1,200.
FAQ
Why are my emails going to spam?
Usually a free From address, a domain without SPF, DKIM and DMARC, an old or bought list, or too many spam reports.
Do spam trigger words still matter?
Less than who you send to: Gmail, Yahoo and Outlook publish rules on authentication, spam reports and unsubscribes, not word lists. Keep subject lines plain.
What's the best time to send an email?
No single time fits every list. Mailchimp's send-time test compares days and times to learn when your own contacts respond (Mailchimp Help: About A/B tests).
Can I buy an email list to grow faster?
Yahoo tells senders not to, and strangers' spam reports count against you. In Canada you also need each person's consent first (CASL, s. 6(1)).
Different for you?
- You're deciding what to send past customers, and the US rules: email and text marketing.
- Your list includes people in Canada: CASL consent.
- You email quotes that didn't close: unsold estimates follow-up.
- You ask for reviews by email: asking for reviews: the rules.
- You'd rather have follow-ups written, sent and answered for you: Conversion Agent.