How to diversify website traffic: 12 ways beyond Google
Short answer Add channels one at a time, cheapest first. Start with free listings that reuse work you've done: Bing Places, Apple Business, directories. Then build what you own: a customer email list, referrals and partners. Video and press come next. Pay for ads last, with a capped test budget. Judge every channel by booked jobs, not visits.
Want help applying this to your business? Talk it through on a free 30-minute call.
Book a callThe 12 ways to get traffic beyond Google search
Here is the full menu, roughly from cheapest to most expensive. The last column is where each one shows up in Google Analytics 4 (GA4), the free tool most sites use to see where visitors come from.
| # | Channel | What it costs | Where GA4 counts it |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Bing and Copilot: a Bing Places listing and Bing Webmaster Tools | Free | Organic Search; Copilot visits in AI Assistant |
| 2 | Apple Maps and Siri: an Apple Business listing | Free | Ask new customers how they found you |
| 3 | AI assistants: ChatGPT, Gemini, Copilot | Free; the work is on your pages and listings | AI Assistant |
| 4 | Directories and review sites: Yelp, your trade's directory | Free listing; upgrades cost extra | Referral |
| 5 | Email and texts to past customers | A sending tool | Email or SMS, once links are tagged |
| 6 | Referrals and partner businesses | Free, or a reward you choose | Ask "How did you hear about us?" |
| 7 | Nextdoor and social pages | Free | Organic Social |
| 8 | YouTube and short videos | Your time | Organic Video |
| 9 | Local press, podcasts, guest articles and talks | Your time | Referral |
| 10 | Search ads on Google or Microsoft | Daily budget you set | Paid Search |
| 11 | Pay-per-lead ads and lead sites | A price per lead | Calls and forms; ask |
| 12 | Facebook and Instagram ads | Daily budget you set | Paid Social, once links are tagged |
Channels 5 and 6 are yours: the contact list and relationships stay if a platform changes its rules. Everything else is rented, because someone else decides who sees you. How to build the owned ones step by step: traffic channels AI can't take.
Which channels should a small business start with?
Start with the ones that copy what you already have. Your Google Business Profile details (name, address, phone, hours, photos) can be reused on Bing, Apple and directories in an afternoon.
- Free listings first (1 to 4). Bing Places is "a free online platform where businesses can create and manage their listings" (Bing Search Blog, October 2025). Apple Business has been "available as a free service in the U.S. and 200+ countries and regions" since April 14, 2026, and its place cards show photos, hours and details "across Apple Maps" (Apple Newsroom). Which directories matter: local citations. Getting named in AI answers: get ChatGPT to recommend you.
- Owned channels next (5 and 6). Every past customer is a contact you already paid to win. Check consent rules before you email or text: email and text marketing; in Canada, CASL consent.
- Content that needs time (7 to 9). A video or a news mention keeps working after you make it, but each one takes hours.
- Paid last (10 to 12). Ads bring visits the day they start and stop the day you stop paying.
Is Bing worth it for traffic beyond Google?
Yes, because it's free and quick. In October 2026, Bing had 9.78% of US search clicks, against Google's 85.45% (StatCounter, which counts clicks to sites using its tracker). Bing Webmaster Tools also reports how often your pages are cited "across Microsoft Copilot, AI-generated summaries in Bing, and select partner integrations" (Bing Webmaster Blog, February 2026). Setup steps: Bing Places for Business.
How much budget does each channel need?
Channels 1 to 9 cost mostly time. Give each one a fixed number of hours a month, and drop it after three months if it brought no customers.
For paid channels, cap the money before you start:
- Search ads. You set an average daily budget. Google may spend more on a busy day, but:
"your campaign spend will never exceed 2 times your average daily budget on a given day, and our system makes sure that in a given billing period, you're never charged more than 30.4 multiplied by your average daily budget amount." (Google Ads Help: Choose your bid and budget)
So $20 a day costs at most $608 a month. How to size it: Google Ads budget.
- Pay-per-lead. Google's pay-per-lead campaigns, which Local Services Ads are moving into, bill differently: "You're charged only when a potential customer contacts your business directly through your ad, rather than when they click on your ad." (Google Ads Help). What's changing: Local Services Ads moving to Google Ads. Angi and Thumbtack also charge per lead: are they worth it.
- Social ads. Same idea: a daily cap, one offer, one area. Run one paid test at a time so you can tell which one worked.
How to compare channels before you fund them: marketing channel evaluation.
Video, press and podcasts: worth the time?
They reach people where they already are. Pew's 2025 survey of 5,022 US adults found 84% use YouTube, 71% Facebook, 50% Instagram and 37% TikTok.
- Video. Short answers to the questions customers ask you on the phone. Clicks from YouTube, TikTok or Vimeo land in GA4's Organic Video channel.
- Press and podcasts. Reporters look for sources through request services. HARO, which Cision shut down on December 9, 2024 (Cision), is back under new owners: it "connects journalists with sources for stories," with "free daily media queries" (HARO site). Answer only requests where you have real expertise.
- Guest articles, newsletters and talks. Write for a trade association's blog, swap mentions with a partner's newsletter, or speak at a local business group. Each one puts a link to you in front of people who already trust the host.
How these also help AI search: off-page SEO for AI search.
How do you measure traffic from each channel?
GA4 sorts every visit into a channel by where it came from. Three steps make the sorting right.
- Tag the links you control. Add UTM tags to links in emails, texts, social posts and ads. Google's examples: utm_source "google, newsletter4, billboard", utm_medium "cpc, banner, email" (Analytics Help: custom URLs). A medium of "email" puts the visit in Email; "sms" puts it in SMS. A Facebook ad link needs a paid medium such as "paid_social", or GA4 files it as Organic Social (Analytics Help: Default channel group).
- Read the AI Assistant channel. GA4 now separates AI chat visits:
"AI Assistant is the channel by which users arrive at your site from sources like ChatGPT, Gemini, Deepseek, Copilot, or Grok. It excludes Google's AI Overviews and AI Mode." (Analytics Help: Default channel group)
Clicks from Google's AI Overviews stay in Organic Search. More: AI traffic.
- Ask every new customer. A friend's tip, a Nextdoor post read on a phone, or a tap to call from Apple Maps often leaves no trace. Save the answer to "How did you hear about us?" with the job.
Why a lot of visits land in Direct: GA4 calls Direct "a saved link or by entering your URL" (Analytics Help), but untagged links count there too. One known cause: browsers by default "Don't send the Referer header to less secure destinations (HTTPS→HTTP)" (MDN Web Docs). If your site still runs on plain http, visitors from secure sites arrive with no source. Moving to https fixes that one cause. Full report guide: traffic sources in GA4.
Count booked jobs per channel, not visits. A channel that sends 40 visits and 4 jobs beats one that sends 400 visits and none.
Example
A roofer adding three free channels
It copies its Google profile to Bing Places and Apple Business, and adds itself to two roofing directories. Total time: one afternoon. Three months later, two of 30 new customers say they found it on Apple Maps. It keeps all three listings; they cost nothing.
An accountant testing one paid channel
It sets search ads at $25 a day: at most $760 a month. It tags its newsletter links with utm_medium=email and asks every new client how they heard of it. After 90 days, ads brought 6 clients at about $380 each in ad cost; the newsletter brought 4 for the cost of the email tool. It keeps the newsletter and cuts the ad budget to the hours that booked.
A Toronto cleaning company starting with owned channels
Before emailing past clients, it checks Canada's anti-spam rules: implied consent from a purchase has a time limit, so it emails only recent clients (CASL consent). Then it asks three moving companies to refer clients after each move.
FAQ
How many channels should I add at once?
One or two, each with a fixed budget or hours and a three-month check. Add more at once and you can't tell which worked.
Should I stop doing SEO?
No. Google still sends most search clicks: 85.45% in the US in October 2026, by StatCounter's count. Add channels next to it. More: is SEO dead.
Why does GA4 show so much Direct traffic?
Direct includes typed addresses and bookmarks, but also untagged links from emails, texts and apps. Tag your own links with UTM parameters to shrink it.
Is HARO still around?
Yes. Cision closed it in December 2024; it now runs under Featured and still sends free daily reporter requests.
Different for you?
- You want your owned channels (email, referrals, partners) built step by step: diversify traffic beyond Google.
- Most of your traffic now comes from ChatGPT or Copilot: AI traffic.
- You need help reading which channel earns the job: marketing attribution basics.
- You want ads tested with a capped budget: Paid Ads Agent.
- You want Google, Bing and AI search to keep sending work: SEO & GEO Agent.