Is it legal to use a fake book review generator?
Not to post reviews of your own book, or to put made-up reader quotes in your ads. The FTC's Rule on the Use of Consumer Reviews and Testimonials took effect on October 21, 2024 (Federal Register). It bans a business from writing or creating a review or testimonial that misrepresents "That the reviewer or testimonialist exists", or that they used the product (16 CFR 465.2). When the FTC announced the rule, it named AI fakes:
"The final rule addresses reviews and testimonials that misrepresent that they are by someone who does not exist, such as AI-generated fake reviews, or who did not have actual experience with the business or its products or services, or that misrepresent the experience of the person giving it." (FTC press release, August 14, 2024)
A self-published author counts as a business. The rule's definition starts with "an individual who sells products or services" (16 CFR 465.1). A testimonial is any promotional message readers would take as a real buyer's opinion, so an invented reader quote on your cover, website or ad is covered too.
Courts can impose civil penalties (fines in a federal lawsuit) for knowing violations (FTC Q&A). In December 2025 the FTC warned 10 companies that the penalty can reach $53,088 per violation (FTC warning-letters release, December 22, 2025). The FTC said its penalty amounts "will remain unchanged during 2026" (Federal Register, September 2026).
One change to know about: in December 2025 the FTC lifted a 2024 order that had banned Rytr, an AI writing tool, from offering a review generator. The FTC said the facts in its complaint did not show Rytr broke the law (FTC Rytr release, December 22, 2025). That case was about the tool's seller. The rule's ban on a business creating fake reviews of its own products is still in force (eCFR, 16 CFR 465.2).
In Canada, the Competition Act applies. The Competition Bureau warns that "Anyone who writes or permits writing reviews that give a false or misleading impression to consumers could be liable under the Competition Act." A court can order penalties of up to C$750,000 for an individual and C$10,000,000 for a corporation on a first occurrence (Competition Bureau Canada).
What Amazon and Goodreads do about fake reviews
Both stores ban fake and paid reviews, and both can act on the author's account, not just the review.
| What an author might try | Amazon | Goodreads |
|---|---|---|
| AI-written or made-up reviews | A "zero-tolerance" policy; AI screens reviews before customers see them | Fake accounts and ratings that "artificially inflate" a book's average are banned |
| Reviews from friends or family | Removed: "a close personal relationship with the product's owner, author, or artist" | Not named; the FTC says family should disclose the tie |
| Cash, gift cards or other rewards | Anything beyond a free or discounted copy "will invalidate a review" | Bans "paid reviews and reviews that have been incentivized in any way" |
| Review swaps with other authors | Removed (Amazon's example: an artist's review of a peer's album given for one in return) | Not named; the FTC says swaps need disclosure (see FAQ) |
| Free or discounted copy, no review required | Allowed | Allowed; the reader must disclose a copy received "in exchange for a review" |
Sources: Amazon: How Amazon maintains a trusted review experience; KDP Help: Customer Reviews; Goodreads review, community and author guidelines.
What can happen to you, not just the review:
- Amazon. The KDP (Kindle Direct Publishing) terms make you subject to Amazon's Community Guidelines and let Amazon "take any action with respect to your account". Amazon can suspend or terminate your account "if we have concerns with your account". If it finds "deceptive, fraudulent, or illegal activity", it may "permanently withhold payments" (KDP Terms and Conditions). Amazon also says it sues review brokers, "those who commit review abuse, and the people who post those reviews."
- Goodreads. It may remove content "or limit its visibility to personal profiles only" (Goodreads review guidelines). For authors, breaking the rules "may result in your account coming under review". The first rule listed: "Don't engage with people who negatively rate or review your books." (Goodreads author guidelines)
Honest ways for authors to get book reviews
Every option below lets the reader decide whether to review and what to say. None buys a rating.
| Method | What it costs | The rule to follow |
|---|---|---|
| Advance review copies (ARCs): free copies sent to readers before or at launch | Your copies | Don't require a review or "attempt to influence the review" (KDP Help). Ask readers to disclose the free copy |
| Ask every reader, the same way | Free | A line at the end of the book or in your newsletter. Amazon doesn't accept "Requests for customer reviews" in the book description (KDP metadata guidelines) |
| Goodreads Giveaway | Print: $119 or $599 to list, plus your books and postage (Goodreads). Kindle: no book or shipping cost | Kindle giveaways (for KDP authors) send "up to 100 copies"; print giveaways can target the US and Canada (Goodreads) |
| NetGalley listing: a site where reviewers and librarians request early copies | $575 (USD) for a 6-month listing; $150 more for a week as a featured title, bought together (NetGalley) | NetGalley says: "Book reviews are not guaranteed." |
| Paid editorial review (a professional critic, not a customer review) | Kirkus Indie: $450, or $599 expedited (Kirkus) | It can come back negative; you may choose not to publish it. Quote it on your site, not in the Amazon description, which doesn't accept "Reviews, quotes, or testimonials" (KDP metadata guidelines) |
The FTC rule treats asking every buyer differently from hand-picking reviewers: its sections on fake reviews a business buys or gets from insiders don't apply to "generalized solicitations to purchasers to post reviews" (16 CFR 465.2(d)). Rewards tied to a positive review are still banned (16 CFR 465.4). In Canada, emailing readers needs consent under Canada's Anti-Spam Legislation: the law on consent before sending commercial emails and texts to people in Canada. More (the anti-spam law): see CASL consent for texting and email.
Example
Illustrative cases with invented numbers.
A debut novelist with zero reviews (US dollars)
A free generator offers 30 five-star reviews to post from five accounts. That is the conduct the FTC rule describes, Amazon blocks and Goodreads bans. Instead, she sends 60 free ebooks to newsletter readers four weeks before launch, asks for an honest review at any rating, and asks them to note the free copy. She lists a Kindle giveaway on Goodreads the same week.
A business author buying an editorial review (US dollars)
He pays $450 for a Kirkus Indie review. It comes back mixed with one strong line. He quotes that line on his website and in his launch email. He leaves it out of the Amazon description.
A Canadian memoirist and her launch team (Canadian dollars)
Forty newsletter subscribers who signed up for updates get a free ebook. She asks each for an honest review and never offers the C$25 gift card a friend suggested: Amazon says a gift card "will invalidate a review".
FAQ
Is it illegal to use AI to help write a book review?
Not under the FTC rule if you're a reader stating your own view; it binds businesses. An author faking readers breaks it, AI or not (16 CFR 465.2).
Can I review my own book under a pen name or a second account?
No. Goodreads bans "creating fake accounts to manipulate book ratings", and the FTC rule requires owners to disclose their tie in their own reviews (16 CFR 465.5).
Can friends and family review my book?
The FTC allows it if they "clearly and conspicuously disclose their relationship" (FTC Q&A). Amazon goes further: it removes reviews from people close to the author.
Do review swaps between authors need a disclosure?
Yes. The FTC says swapping authors must disclose the tie, "since bad reviews of each other's books could jeopardize the arrangement." (FTC Endorsement Guides Q&A) Amazon removes swaps.
Can I use AI to get feedback on my manuscript?
Yes. Private feedback isn't a review; the rule covers reviews "published to a website or platform" (16 CFR 465.1). Don't publish the output as a reader's opinion.
Different for you?
- You run a local business and want more Google reviews: Asking for reviews: FTC rules and text consent.
- Someone posted a fake review about you on Google: Respond to negative Google reviews and remove fake ones. On Amazon, use the Report link under the review (KDP Help: Customer Reviews).
- You publish AI-assisted articles on your author website: Does Google penalize AI content?
- You want a newsletter that brings in readers and reviews: Email and text marketing.
- You'd rather have your website found in search and AI answers: SEO & GEO Agent.