Products SEO & GEO Agent Paid Ads Agent Website Agent Conversion Agent
How it works Pricing FAQ Blog Book a call

Online reputation management for startups: a first-year plan

Updated · 7 min read

Want help applying this to your business? Talk it through on a free 30-minute call.

Book a call

The first-year plan

Online reputation management (ORM) means watching and shaping what people find when they look you up. For a new business, it is mostly setup.

WhenWhat to do
Before you openClaim your Google listing and add an opening date. Take the same name on Facebook and Instagram.
Opening weekClaim Apple Business, Bing Places and Yelp. Turn on review notifications. Create Google Alerts for your business name and your own. Search your name on Google, Bing and ChatGPT, and save what you see.
Months 1 to 3Ask every customer for a Google review, the same way, with no reward. Reply to each one.
The first bad reviewReply once, fix the problem privately, report it only if it breaks a rule.
Every month15 minutes: read new reviews and alerts, log in to each listing.
Month 12Search your name again and compare.

Before you open: claim your listings

Google first. Adding or claiming a Business Profile, your free listing on Google Search and Maps, costs nothing (Your free business listing on Google Search and Maps: hours, photos, reviews, services and contact details. More Help: Add or claim your Business Profile). Search Google Maps first: if a listing exists, claim it instead of making a second. If a web designer or former partner controls it, request access. The owner has 3 days to answer; after that, "you may have the option to claim the profile" (Request ownership of a Business Profile). Fill in every field: profiles "with complete and accurate info are more likely to show up in local search results" (Tips to improve your local ranking on Google).

List it before opening day. You can enter an opening date up to a year ahead. Once you verify, "your profile shows up on Google 90 days prior to your opening date," with a "Recently opened" tag for 90 days after you open. Until then, nobody can review you:

"To prevent inaccurate information from appearing on Google, users cannot suggest edits to your business information or post content, such as reviews or photos, on your Business Profile until your business is officially open." (Google Business Profile Help: Add a business opening date)

Then the rest, as soon as each one lets you.

ListingWhat to know
Apple Business (replaced Business Connect)Apple announced it as a free service from April 14, 2026; businesses "need to first claim their location on Maps" (Apple Newsroom). Location management is offered in the US and Canada (Apple Support: feature availability).
Bing PlacesSetup and copying your Google listing: Bing Places.
YelpFree to claim. Yelp may mark a page unclaimed if the owner "hasn't logged into their Yelp for Business account in the last 90 days" (Yelp for Business).
Facebook, Instagram, LinkedInTake the same handle on each, even before you post.

Which directories come next: local citations. Link every profile from your website. Google's Organization structured data can list them too, which Google says helps it "disambiguate your organization in search results" (Google Search Central). How: schema markup.

How to monitor your online reputation for free

What to watchFree tool
New Google reviewsBusiness Profile notifications by email (Google Business Profile Help: Manage your notifications)
Your name on news sites, blogs and forumsGoogle Alerts: "You'll get emails whenever we find matching search results" (Google Search Help: Create an alert)
YelpLog in at least every 90 days, or Yelp may show the page as unclaimed
What AI assistants say about youAsk them monthly: the ChatGPT test

Alerts report only what Google Search finds, so posts in private groups or behind a login won't reach you.

How many reviews does a new business need?

Google sets no number, but shoppers do. In BrightLocal's 2026 survey of 1,002 US adults, 47% won't use a business with fewer than 20 reviews, and only 9% would use one with five or fewer. 74% look for reviews from the last three months. Google adds: "More reviews and positive ratings can help your business's local ranking" (Tips to improve your local ranking on Google). So aim for a steady flow, not a launch-week burst.

How to ask within the rules:

Your first bad review: what to do

It hurts more when you're new. Google's star score is "the average of all ratings published on Google" (Understand review scores). One 1-star after four 5-stars drops you to 4.2. After forty, you'd still show 4.9.

  1. Check it's a real customer against your bookings or invoices.
  2. Reply once, in public, briefly. Google's rule for the tone:
"Never share a reviewer's private information or engage in personal attacks. If a situation is complex, politely request that the reviewer contact you via phone or email to resolve the issue privately." (Google Business Profile Help: Tips to get more reviews)
  1. Fix the problem privately. The reviewer is notified of your reply and "can still change their review after reading your reply" (Manage customer reviews). A refund is fine, but not one conditional on a changed review: Google bans incentives for "revision or removal of a negative review," and Yelp says "you can't offer incentives for users to remove reviews."
  2. Report it only if it breaks a rule, such as fake or off-topic. Google: "Do not report a review just because you disagree with it or dislike it" (Report inappropriate reviews). Steps and appeals: negative and fake Google reviews.
  3. Never threaten the reviewer. In the US, using "an unfounded or groundless legal threat, a physical threat, intimidation, or a public false accusation" to get a review removed breaks the FTC's rule (16 CFR 465.7).

Shortcuts that backfire

ShortcutThe rule
Fake reviews, or writing your ownUS: the FTC's review rule bans fake reviews, and owner reviews that hide the tie (16 CFR 465.2, 465.5). Google can stop new reviews for a set time, unpublish existing ones, and display "a warning to let consumers know that fake reviews were removed" (Restrictions for policy violations).
Reviews from family, staff or partnersGoogle removes reviews "based on a conflict of interest," including employment and "familial relationships" (Google Maps policy). US: owners who ask relatives or staff for reviews must tell them to disclose the tie (16 CFR 465.5). Canada: "employees must disclose all connections they have with the business," and "Anyone who writes or permits writing reviews that give a false or misleading impression to consumers could be liable" (Competition Bureau, 2024).
Buying followers or likesUS: buying fake social media indicators to misrepresent your influence for a commercial purpose is banned (16 CFR 465.8).
A "no negative reviews" clause in your contract or online termsUS: illegal in form contracts under the Consumer Review Fairness Act (FTC).
Press releases stuffed with keyword linksGoogle calls "links with optimized anchor text in articles, guest posts, or press releases distributed on other sites" link spam (Google Search Central: Spam policies).

Some guides recommend "parasite SEO": posting on big sites to fill page one with your name. Your own profile or press release there is fine; Google lists press release sites and sites built for user content among examples that don't break its site reputation policy (Spam policies). Keyword-stuffed links do break the rules.

If something negative ranks for your name, reply where you can and correct it at the source. Google removes pages only for set reasons: removing information from Google.

Example

Illustrative cases.

A bakery opening in April

In January the owner adds the opening date and verifies, so the profile shows about 90 days early. Reviews open on opening day; the review QR code is on every receipt.

A bookkeeping startup with four 5-star reviews

A 1-star arrives: the average falls to 4.2. The client is real and an invoice was wrong. The owner replies once, fixes it and refunds USD 150 without mentioning the review. The client edits it to 4 stars on her own: 4.8.

A landscaping startup in Canada

A co-founder's sister offers five stars. They decline and put the review link on every spring invoice instead. The profile passes 20 reviews by summer.

FAQ

Do I need reputation management software in my first year?

Usually not. Notifications, Google Alerts and a monthly login cover one location. Paid tools earn their cost when reviews outrun your time.

Can I reply to Google reviews before my profile is verified?

No. Google says you must verify your business before you can reply to reviews.

Can a reputation company remove bad reviews?

Only the reviewer or the platform can, and Google removes only reviews that break its policies. Be wary of anyone promising to remove fair ones.

Different for you?

Keep learning

NextKnowledge panel schema markup: feed Google the right factsWhich Organization schema facts Google reads for a knowledge panel: name, logo, sameAs profiles, where the code goes, and how to test it.

Ask us one question

One line is enough. We reply by email.

Sources

  1. Google Business Profile Help: Add or claim your Business Profile
  2. Google Business Profile Help: Request ownership of a Business Profile
  3. Google Business Profile Help: Add a business opening date
  4. Google Business Profile Help: Manage your notifications
  5. Google Business Profile Help: Tips to get more reviews
  6. Google Business Profile Help: Manage customer reviews
  7. Google Business Profile Help: Report inappropriate reviews
  8. Google Business Profile Help: Understand review scores
  9. Google Business Profile Help: Tips to improve your local ranking on Google
  10. Google Business Profile Help: Restrictions for policy violations
  11. Google Maps: Prohibited and restricted content
  12. Google Search Help: Create an alert
  13. Google Search Central: Organization structured data
  14. Google Search Central: Spam policies for Google web search
  15. Apple Newsroom: Introducing Apple Business (March 24, 2026)
  16. Apple Support: Apple Business feature availability
  17. Yelp for Business: Why claim your Business Page on Yelp
  18. Yelp Business Help Center: Don't Ask for Reviews
  19. BrightLocal: Local Consumer Review Survey 2026
  20. 16 CFR Part 465: Rule on the Use of Consumer Reviews and Testimonials (eCFR)
  21. FTC: Consumer Review Fairness Act, what businesses need to know
  22. Competition Bureau Canada: Online reviews posted by employees, businesses could be liable (January 2024)