How to do an SEO audit: technical, on-page and off-page
Short answer Check six areas in order: can Google index your key pages (technical), does each page match what buyers search (on-page), who links to and reviews you (off-page), your Google Business Profile (local), language and country versions if you have them (international), and AI answers. Free tools from Google and Bing cover a small site. Fix what blocks Google first.
Want help applying this to your business? Talk it through on a free 30-minute call.
Book a callHow to do an SEO audit, step by step
Work top to bottom. Each step depends on the one above it: a page Google can't index can't rank, however good its words or links.
| Step | Area | The question | Free tool |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0 | Baseline | What do search visits bring in today? | Search Console Performance, GA4 |
| 1 | Technical | Can Google find, index and load your key pages? | Search Console Page indexing report, URL Inspection, PageSpeed Insights |
| 2 | On-page | Does each page match what a buyer searches? | Your own eyes, Rich Results Test |
| 3 | Off-page | Who links to you and talks about you? | Search Console Links report, Bing Webmaster Tools |
| 4 | Local | Does your Google Business Profile show up nearby? | Google Search and Maps on a phone |
| 5 | International | Do language or country versions reach the right people? | URL Inspection, your hreflang tags |
| 6 | AI search | Do AI answers mention you correctly? | Asking ChatGPT, Gemini and Copilot |
A small site (under about 50 pages) can be done in an afternoon. Write each problem in one list as you go; ranking that list is the last step.
Free crawlers fill gaps. Bing Webmaster Tools is free, and Bing says its Site Scan finds "broken links, duplicate tags, and missing metadata." Screaming Frog's SEO Spider crawls up to 500 URLs per crawl without a paid licence, per its user guide. Lighthouse, built into Chrome, has "audits for performance, accessibility, SEO, and more."
Before you start: write down a baseline
Without a starting number, you can't tell later whether a fix worked. Record three things:
- Search Console Performance, last 3 months: clicks, impressions (how often you appeared) and the searches that brought them. How to read it: Google Search Console for a small business.
- Leads from search: calls, form fills and bookings from organic (unpaid) search in GA4, set up as key events. See GA4 key events.
- Your money pages: the 5–15 pages that sell, usually home, each service, and location pages.
Bounce rate is less useful than it sounds. In GA4 it is simply "the opposite of the engagement rate": the share of visits under 10 seconds with one page and no key event, per Google Analytics Help. A visitor who reads your phone number and calls can count as a bounce.
Technical SEO audit: can Google reach your pages?
Open Search Console's Page indexing report and check that every money page is indexed. Don't chase 100%:
"You should not expect all URLs on your site to be indexed, only the canonical pages" (Search Console Help: Page indexing report)
Canonical means the one version of a page Google picks to show. Duplicates, filter pages and old redirects should stay out.
For each money page that isn't indexed:
- Paste it into URL Inspection. It tells you whether Google may index the page and why not.
- Look for a noindex tag or a robots.txt block. A site builder's "hide from search engines" box often adds one. Robots.txt doesn't hide pages: Google says it "is not a mechanism for keeping a web page out of Google." Use noindex or a password for that.
- Sitemap: helpful, not required. Google says a site of "about 500 pages or fewer" that links its pages well may not need one. Most site builders make one anyway; submit it in Search Console.
Then check the page itself:
- Phone version. Google uses the mobile version of a site's content "for indexing and ranking," so anything missing on the phone version is missing for Google. Google's Mobile-Friendly Test and Search Console's Mobile Usability report were retired on December 1, 2023; Google pointed owners to Lighthouse instead.
- Speed. Google's Core Web Vitals targets are a loading time (LCP) under 2.5 seconds, a response to taps (INP) under 200 milliseconds, and layout shift (CLS) under 0.1. Run PageSpeed Insights on your money pages, not just the home page. Details: Core Web Vitals.
- HTTPS. The padlock. Google's page experience guide lists "secure (HTTPS)" among the things to check, next to Core Web Vitals and avoiding intrusive pop-ups.
On-page SEO audit: does each page match the search?
Go through your money pages one at a time. For each, write the one search it should win ("emergency plumber Tacoma"), then check:
| Check | Pass |
|---|---|
| Title tag | Unique, names the service and place |
| Main heading (H1) | Says the same thing in plain words |
| Content | Answers price, area, process, proof and how to book |
| Internal links | Other pages link to it with descriptive words |
| Structured data | Passes the Rich Results Test, if you use it |
| Duplicates | No two pages chase the same search |
Skip the meta keywords box: Google "doesn't use the keywords meta tag," per its SEO Starter Guide. Word counts and keyword density aren't targets either. The full list: on-page SEO for service pages.
The most common finding on a small site is a gap, not an error: a service you sell with no page of its own. Add those to the list.
Off-page SEO audit: links, reviews and mentions
Off-page means signals from other websites. Open Search Console's Links report for who links to you. Google calls it "a sample," not every link. Bing Webmaster Tools adds "referring domains, anchor text, and link profiles" for your site and competitors.
Look for three things:
- Real local links missing: suppliers, associations, sponsorships and partners that know you but don't link. How to earn them: backlinks for a local business.
- Links you paid for or traded. If you or a past agency bought links, that's the real risk.
- Wrong facts about you: old phone numbers or addresses on directories.
Don't disavow because a tool flags "toxic" links. Google says:
"In most cases, Google can assess which links to trust without additional guidance, so most sites will not need to use this tool." (Search Console Help: Disavow links to your site)
Disavow only if you have many spammy links and they caused, or likely will cause, a manual action. Social media shares aren't a ranking shortcut; see does social media help SEO.
Local SEO audit: your Business Profile
If customers come from nearby, this step can matter more than the website. Google says local results depend on relevance, distance and prominence, and prominence includes "how many websites link to your business and how many reviews you have" (Business Profile Help).
On a phone, search your main service plus your town, then check:
- Your profile appears, with the right category, hours, phone and website link.
- There is only one profile per location.
- Your name, address and phone match on your website, Bing Places, Apple and Yelp.
- Your review count and rating next to the top three rivals.
Distance you can't change. Relevance and prominence you can. The full checklist: local SEO checklist and ranking higher on Google Maps.
International SEO audit: language and country versions
Skip this step if your site has one language and serves one country. It applies if you have a Spanish or French version, or separate US and Canadian pages.
Google's rules to check against:
- Each language on its own URL, with the main content translated, not just the menu. Google decides a page's language from its visible text and doesn't use "code-level language information such as lang attributes, or the URL."
- Hreflang tags link the versions both ways. Hreflang is code that tells Google "this page also exists in French." Google lists "Missing return links" as a common mistake: if page X points to page Y, Y must point back.
- No automatic language redirects. Google says to avoid redirecting people based on what you think their language may be; offer a switch instead.
- Geo meta tags do nothing. Google "ignores locational meta tags (like geo.position or distribution)." Local addresses, phone numbers, currency and your Business Profile are among the signals it uses.
A business serving both countries in English can mark pages en-US and en-CA and add a catchall English version, as Google's own example does with en-CA. In Quebec, French is a legal matter, not only SEO: multilingual website SEO.
AI search check: ChatGPT, Gemini and AI Overviews
Google says there are "no additional requirements to appear in AI Overviews or AI Mode." So steps 1 to 4 are also the AI audit for Google. For other assistants, ask them the questions customers would ask and note whether you appear and whether the facts are right: the 20-question ChatGPT test. Check your robots.txt isn't blocking AI crawlers by accident: blocking AI crawlers.
Turn the audit into a fix list
Rank by damage to leads, not by how many warnings a tool shows:
- Blocks: money pages not indexed, wrong phone number, suspended or duplicate profile.
- Gaps: services or towns with no page; a profile missing categories or hours.
- Weak matches: titles, headings and content that don't fit the search.
- Authority: fewer reviews and local links than rivals.
- Polish: speed tweaks, alt text, schema extras.
Recheck the baseline numbers monthly. Results take time: how long SEO takes.
Example
Illustrative cases. The numbers are invented.
A 15-page roofing site (US dollars)
The audit finds the "metal roofing" page marked noindex by an old site-builder setting, and no page for gutter work, a third of jobs. Fixes: untick the box ($0), write a gutter page (about $300 from a writer). The 400 "toxic" links the free tool flagged are left alone.
A bilingual clinic in Ottawa (Canadian dollars)
The French pages auto-redirect anyone with a French browser and have no hreflang tags, so Google shows French searchers the English pages. A developer adds hreflang both ways and a language switch for about $800.
An accountant with 300 blog posts
Search Console shows 180 posts not indexed and the three service pages ranking nowhere. The audit's top item isn't the posts: it's that service pages have 80 words each. They get rewritten first.
FAQ
How often should I do an SEO audit?
Google sets no schedule. A full audit yearly, and after a redesign, a domain or platform move, or a sudden traffic drop, fits most small sites.
Can I do an SEO audit myself for free?
Yes, for a small site. Search Console, GA4, PageSpeed Insights, the Rich Results Test and Bing Webmaster Tools are free. What takes skill is deciding which findings matter.
What's the first thing to check?
Whether your money pages are indexed. Search site:yourdomain.com on Google, then check each key page in URL Inspection.
Should I fix every warning an audit tool shows?
No. Tools flag non-indexed duplicates and "toxic" links that Google itself says are usually fine. Fix what blocks leads first.
Different for you?
- Your site isn't on Google at all: website not showing on Google.
- Pages say "crawled, currently not indexed": page not indexed in Search Console.
- Traffic fell after a redesign: traffic dropped after a website redesign.
- Traffic fell after a Google update: traffic dropped after a core update.
- Search Console shows a manual action: Google manual action.
- You'd rather have the audit done and the fixes made: SEO & GEO Agent.