Website audit checklist: SEO, speed and user experience
Short answer A website audit asks five questions in order: can Google find and index your pages, does the site load fast on a phone, does each page say what you do and where, can a visitor call or book easily, and is it secure and accessible. Free tools cover most small sites: Search Console, PageSpeed Insights, Lighthouse and a crawler.
Want help applying this to your business? Talk it through on a free 30-minute call.
Book a callWebsite audit checklist: the five areas, in order
Work top to bottom. A problem in an early row can cancel every fix below it: a page Google can't index won't rank however good its words are, and a page that ranks earns nothing if the phone number doesn't work.
| # | Area | What to check | Free tool |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Can Google find it? | Key pages indexed; nothing blocked by mistake; no broken internal links | Search Console (Page indexing, URL Inspection), a crawler |
| 2 | Does it work on a phone? | Loads fast on mobile; same content as desktop; no layout jumps | PageSpeed Insights, Search Console (Core Web Vitals) |
| 3 | Does each page say what you do? | One page per service; unique titles; city and service named in plain words | A crawler (titles, duplicates), your own eyes |
| 4 | Can a visitor book? | Tap-to-call works; book button visible without scrolling; short form; no pop-up covering the screen | Your phone, Google Analytics |
| 5 | Is it safe and usable for everyone? | HTTPS on every page; images have alt text; readable contrast; works with a keyboard | Browser padlock, Lighthouse |
Areas 1, 2 and 5 are mostly about Google. Area 4 is about leads: Google doesn't score it, but it decides whether a visit becomes a call.
Which website audit tools do you need?
A small business site rarely needs paid software. These cover every row above:
| Tool | What it checks | Cost (November 2026) |
|---|---|---|
| Google Search Console | Which pages are indexed, why others aren't, real-visitor speed, security issues | Free |
| PageSpeed Insights | One page's speed on mobile and desktop, with real-visitor data where Google has it | Free |
| Lighthouse (built into Chrome) | Performance, accessibility, SEO and best-practice audits for one page | Free |
| Screaming Frog SEO Spider | Crawls the site like Google: broken links, redirects, titles, duplicates | Free up to 500 URLs per crawl; a yearly licence removes the limit |
| Ahrefs Webmaster Tools (now called Ahrefs Free) | Site audit and backlink list for sites you verify | Free, 5,000 crawl credits a month per project |
| Google Analytics 4 | Where visitors leave, which pages lead to calls and forms | Free |
Lighthouse describes itself plainly:
"Lighthouse is an open-source, automated tool to help you improve the quality of web pages." (Chrome for Developers: Introduction to Lighthouse)
Retired tools older checklists still name:
- Mobile-Friendly Test and the Mobile Usability report. Google removed them in December 2023. Use Lighthouse or PageSpeed Insights instead.
- First Input Delay (FID). Replaced by Interaction to Next Paint (INP) as a Core Web Vital in March 2024.
- "Coverage report." In Search Console today, the report is called Page indexing.
How to read Search Console's reports: Google Search Console for a small business.
Technical checks: can Google find your pages?
Open Search Console's Page indexing report and check that every page you sell from (home, each service, each location, contact) is indexed. A long "not indexed" list is normal; Google doesn't index everything. Act only when a page you need is missing: what "crawled, not indexed" means.
Then check the three usual self-inflicted blocks:
- robots.txt blocking pages. It controls crawling, not search listings:
"it is not a mechanism for keeping a web page out of Google. To keep a web page out of Google, block indexing with noindex or password-protect the page." (Google Search Central: Introduction to robots.txt)
- A leftover noindex tag. It can happen after a redesign, when the test site's "hide from search" setting goes live. URL Inspection shows it.
- Broken internal links. A crawler lists every link that hits a 404 (page not found). Point each one at the live page.
A sitemap matters less than most checklists say. Google says a site of "about 500 pages or fewer" that is well linked may not need one, and WordPress, Wix and similar builders usually create one for you (Google Search Central: Learn about sitemaps).
HTTPS: every page should load with the padlock and plain http should redirect to https. Google called it "a very lightweight signal" when it began using it in 2014 (Google Search Central Blog), so do it mainly for visitor trust: Chrome shows people whether a site's connection is secure (Google Search Central: Understanding page experience).
Speed and phone checks: does it work on mobile?
Google ranks your phone version, not your desktop one:
"Google uses the mobile version of a site's content, crawled with the smartphone agent, for indexing and ranking." (Google Search Central: Mobile site and mobile-first indexing best practices)
So check that nothing important (prices, service areas, reviews) is hidden or cut on mobile. Google says to make sure "your mobile site contains the same content as your desktop site."
For speed, Google's Core Web Vitals have three targets: main content shown within 2.5 seconds (LCP), taps answered in under 200 milliseconds (INP), and a layout shift score under 0.1 (CLS) (Google Search Central: Understanding Core Web Vitals). Use the Core Web Vitals report in Search Console for real visitors; PageSpeed Insights' lab score is for finding causes.
Don't chase a perfect score. Google is clear that relevance comes first:
"Google Search always seeks to show the most relevant content, even if the page experience is sub-par." (Google Search Central: Understanding page experience)
What usually slows a small business site and how much speed matters: Core Web Vitals and ranking.
User experience checks: can a visitor call or book?
No tool does this well. Do it yourself, on your own phone, on mobile data, as a stranger would:
- Search your main service and city, tap your result, and time how long until you could act.
- Tap the phone number. Does it dial?
- Find the book or quote button without scrolling. Is it there on every service page?
- Fill in the form. Count the fields; each one you can drop is one less reason to quit.
- Look for anything covering the screen on arrival: cookie banner, chat bubble, pop-up offer.
- Open your menu. Can you reach every service in two taps?
Then check Google Analytics for the pages where most visitors leave. Where people drop off before booking, and what to change: website not getting leads.
Accessibility is part of the same check. Run Lighthouse's accessibility audit, then try the site with only a keyboard. Missing alt text, low contrast and unlabeled form fields are the common failures. US and Canadian rules differ; see ADA website compliance.
Page checks: does each page say what you do?
Each service needs its own page, with a unique title naming the service and place. A crawler lists duplicate and missing titles in one pass.
- Meta descriptions are your pitch in the results, not a fix for ranking. Google says it uses them only sometimes, when it thinks they describe the page better than the page text does (Google Search Central: Meta descriptions and snippets).
- Headings: use them to make the page easy to scan. Google says order doesn't matter to Search: "from Google Search perspective, it doesn't matter if you're using them out of order" (Google Search Central: SEO Starter Guide). The one-H1 rule is not a Google rule.
- Meta keywords: delete the task. "Google Search doesn't use the keywords meta tag" (SEO Starter Guide).
- Internal links: each service page should be linked from the home page or menu, and from related services. A crawler shows pages nothing links to.
- Review stars from your own testimonials: Google shows local business review stars "only for sites that capture reviews about other local businesses" (Google Search Central: Review snippet structured data). Marking up your own testimonials won't earn stars.
What a service page needs in full: on-page SEO for service pages. Which schema is worth adding: local business schema markup. Ahrefs' free backlink list shows who links to you; what to do with it: backlinks for a local business.
What to fix first after a website audit
An audit tool will hand you hundreds of "issues." Sort them by damage, not by count:
| Priority | Fix | Why |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Anything stopping contact: broken phone link, failing form, site down | Every lost visitor is a lost lead today |
| 2 | Key pages not indexed, blocked or noindexed | They can't be found at all |
| 3 | Booking friction on mobile: buried button, long form, covering pop-up | Visitors leave before they reach you |
| 4 | Slow mobile pages, broken links, missing HTTPS | Hurts trust and some ranking |
| 5 | Missing or duplicate titles, thin service pages | Helps the right searches find the right page |
| Skip | Perfect Lighthouse score, one-H1 rule, meta keywords, review markup on testimonials | Google doesn't reward them |
Run the full checklist after any redesign, platform move or domain change; that is when most self-inflicted damage happens (traffic dropped after a redesign). Otherwise a quick monthly look at Search Console and a full pass once or twice a year fits most small sites.
Example
A plumber with a new website
A three-person plumbing company launches a new US$4,000 site. Two weeks later, Search Console shows only the home page indexed. URL Inspection reveals the builder's "hide from search engines" box still ticked. Unticking it and requesting indexing for the eight service pages is the whole fix; everything else on the audit can wait.
A dental office with good rankings and few bookings
A dental office ranks well for "dentist near me" in its town but books few new patients online. The phone test shows a cookie banner covering half the screen and the booking button below three photos. Shrinking the banner and moving the button to the top are the first fixes, before any SEO work.
A Toronto accounting firm with 300 audit "errors"
A free crawl lists 300 issues, mostly missing meta descriptions on old blog posts. The firm fixes the five that matter: two broken links to its booking page, a slow mobile home page and two service pages with the same title. The other 295 go on a low-priority list. Budget: about CA$600 of a developer's time.
FAQ
How long does a website audit take?
For a site under 50 pages, about an afternoon with free tools. Fixing what it finds can take longer, depending on who controls the site.
Do I need a paid tool for a website audit?
Usually not. Search Console, PageSpeed Insights and Lighthouse are free, and Screaming Frog's free version crawls up to 500 URLs, enough for most small sites.
What is the difference between an SEO audit and a website audit?
An SEO audit asks whether Google can find and rank your pages. A website audit also asks whether visitors can use it and contact you.
Is Google's Mobile-Friendly Test still available?
No. Google retired it and the Mobile Usability report in December 2023. Use Lighthouse in Chrome or PageSpeed Insights instead.
Does a low PageSpeed score hurt my ranking?
A little at most. Google still shows the most relevant page when page experience is poor. Fix speed for real visitors, not a number.
Different for you?
- Your problem is Google Maps, not your website: the profile side is in the local SEO checklist.
- Traffic fell after a redesign: start with why traffic dropped after a website redesign.
- Important pages show as not indexed: see crawled or discovered, currently not indexed.
- People visit but don't book: see website not getting leads.
- You'd rather have the fixes done: see the Website agent or the SEO agent.