Products SEO & GEO Agent Paid Ads Agent Website Agent Conversion Agent
How it works Pricing FAQ Blog Book a call

How to do an SEO audit yourself: a step-by-step guide

Updated · 9 min read

Short answer Set aside two to three hours and use free tools: Google Search Console, PageSpeed Insights and a free crawler. Check, in order, whether Google indexes your pages, what's broken, speed and security, whether each page matches a search, internal links, and pages close to page one. Write every problem into one list, ranked by how much it costs you.

Want help applying this to your business? Talk it through on a free 30-minute call.

Book a call

How to do an SEO audit yourself: the steps in order

An SEO audit is a checkup of how well search engines can find, read and rank your website. You can run one yourself. Work top to bottom, because a problem early in the list makes the later ones pointless: a page Google hasn't indexed can't rank, however good its title is.

StepFree toolWhat you're looking forTime
1. IndexingSearch Console, a `site:` searchPages that should be in Google but aren't20 min
2. Broken thingsA crawler (Screaming Frog or Ahrefs Webmaster Tools)Dead pages, redirect loops, missing titles30 min
3. Speed, phone, securityPageSpeed Insights, Search ConsoleSlow pages, layout jumps, no HTTPS20 min
4. Page matches a searchYour own eyes, the crawler's exportOne clear page per service, with a clear title30 min
5. Internal linksThe crawlerPages nothing links to15 min
6. Pages near page oneSearch Console Performance reportPages Google already shows, just not high enough20 min
7. Two competitorsA Google searchWhat their pages answer that yours don't20 min

Times are rough for a site under about 100 pages. Everything goes into one fix list, shown at the end.

What you need before you start

Three things, all free:

  • Google Search Console, verified for your site. It shows what Google indexes and which searches show your pages. Setup takes minutes; see Google Search Console for a small business. New accounts need a few days to fill with data.
  • A crawler: a program that visits every page on your site the way Google does and lists what it finds. Screaming Frog's free version crawls up to 500 URLs; its user guide says a £199-a-year licence removes that limit. Ahrefs Webmaster Tools is free for sites you verify, with 5,000 crawl credits per site each month, and its site audit checks for 170+ issues.
  • A spreadsheet for the fix list.

Step 1: Is Google indexing your pages?

Search `site:yourdomain.com` on Google for a quick look. It's only a sample. Google's own help page warns:

"However, site: may not list all indexed URLs and doesn't rank results; results can appear random." (Google Search Central: site: search operator)

For the real answer, open Search Console's Pages report (Page indexing). Then check that your money pages, the ones for each service and your contact page, are indexed. Don't chase 100%:

"Don't expect every URL on your site to be indexed." (Search Console Help: Page indexing report)

Google says a page left out for a good reason is fine: a deliberate noindex tag, a duplicate, or a 404 (page not found) for something you removed. Paste any important page that isn't indexed into the URL Inspection tool at the top of Search Console to see why. The common reasons are explained in crawled or discovered, currently not indexed.

One common mix-up: robots.txt, the file that tells crawlers where not to go, doesn't hide a page from Google. Google says robots.txt "is not a mechanism for keeping a web page out of Google"; to keep a page out, it says to use noindex or a password.

Step 2: What's broken?

Run the crawler on your homepage and sort by status code. Each code is the server's reply when the page is asked for.

What you seeWhat it meansFix
404 on a page you link toA dead linkPoint the link at a live page, or redirect the old address
A redirect to a redirectA chain: page A sends to B, which sends to CPoint A straight at C
Missing or duplicate titlesGoogle has less to go onWrite one unique title per page (step 4)
5xx errorsThe server failedTell your web host or developer

On redirects, the type matters for which address Google shows. Google's redirect guide says a permanent redirect (301) tells it "the redirect target should be canonical", meaning the new address is the one to show in results. A temporary one (302) keeps the old address in results. Google doesn't publish a percentage of "ranking power" each type passes, so ignore claims that a 302 loses most of it. Use a 301 when a page has moved for good.

Step 3: Is the site fast, readable on a phone and secure?

Paste your homepage and your busiest service page into PageSpeed Insights. Read the top part first: it's real visitors' data from the last 28 days, if your site has enough traffic. Google's targets for its three Core Web Vitals:

MeasureWhat it meansGood
LCP (Largest Contentful Paint)How fast the main content appearsWithin 2.5 seconds
INP (Interaction to Next Paint)How fast the page reacts to a tapUnder 200 milliseconds
CLS (Cumulative Layout Shift)How much the layout jumps while loadingUnder 0.1

Keep it in proportion. Google says page experience matters, but:

"Google Search always seeks to show the most relevant content, even if the page experience is sub-par." (Google Search Central: Understanding page experience)

For phones, Google retired its Mobile-Friendly Test and the Mobile Usability report on December 1, 2023. Open your pages on your own phone instead, and run Lighthouse (built into Chrome's developer tools) for a lab report. In Search Console, the HTTPS report shows any pages not served securely. More on speed: Core Web Vitals.

Export the crawler's list of titles and main headings. Read them as a stranger would. Each service you sell should have its own page, and its title should name the service and, for a local business, the place. Google's title guidance warns against "repeated or boilerplate text" in titles, like "Home | Smith Co" on every page.

Flag pages that try to cover five services at once, pages with no real text, and two pages chasing the same search. The full page checklist is in on-page SEO for service pages.

In the crawler, look for pages with zero internal links pointing to them (often called orphan pages). Google's rule is plain:

"Every page you care about should have a link from at least one other page on your site." (Google Search Central: Link best practices)

Link each service page from your menu or homepage, and link related pages to each other with words that say where the link goes ("drain cleaning prices", not "click here").

Step 6: Which pages are close to page one?

This is where an audit pays off fastest. In Search Console's Performance report, turn on average position, click the Pages tab and sort by impressions (how often Google showed the page). Pages with many impressions and an average position around 8 to 20 are already in Google's eye, just on the bottom of page one or on page two. Open each one, check the searches it shows for (the Queries tab), and make sure the page answers them: price range, area, what's included, photos of real work.

Google's traffic-drop guide suggests comparing the last 3 months with the previous period or year over year, which also shows pages slowly losing ground. For whether to update, merge or delete those, see content decay.

Step 7: What do two competitors do better?

Search your main service and town on Google. Open the two businesses that rank above you and note what their page answers that yours doesn't: prices, service areas, FAQs, reviews, photos. Don't copy; fill the gap with your own facts. For a page-by-page look at a rival's site, see Screaming Frog competitor analysis. If you serve customers locally, add your Google Business Profile checks from the local SEO checklist.

Turn your SEO audit into a fix list

An audit with no list is just reading. Put every finding in one sheet and sort it in this order:

  1. Blocks Google: important pages not indexed, a noindex tag left on by mistake.
  2. Broken: dead links, redirect chains, server errors.
  3. Near page one: the pages from step 6.
  4. Everything else: titles, speed, internal links, competitor gaps.
ProblemPagesFixWhoDone by
Water heater page not indexed1Remove noindex tag, request indexingWeb personFriday
Old /services address returns 4041301 to /plumbing-services/Web personFriday
"Drain cleaning" page at position 111Add prices, area, photosOwner2 weeks

Google's Starter Guide says some changes show "in a few hours, others could take several months", so write the date you fixed each item and check back after a month.

How often should you audit your own site?

Google sets no schedule. A full pass once or twice a year suits most small business sites, plus a short monthly look at Search Console (see is my SEO working?). Run one right away after a redesign, a move to a new platform, or a sudden traffic drop.

Example

Illustrative cases with invented numbers.

A plumber's 40-page site (US dollars)

Step 1 finds the water heater page missing from Google: a noindex tag left from the build. Step 6 shows "drain cleaning" at position 11 with 900 impressions a month. Fix list: remove the tag, then add "from $150" pricing and job photos to the drain page. Two hours of audit, one afternoon of fixes.

An accountant near Vancouver (Canadian dollars)

The crawl finds 12 old blog posts redirecting twice after a site move, and the tax services page has no links except from a footer. Fix: point each old address straight at its new page, and link tax services from the homepage.

A cleaning company that skipped speed

PageSpeed Insights shows LCP at 4 seconds from a huge homepage photo. It goes on the list, but third: two service pages weren't indexed at all, and those come first.

FAQ

Can I do an SEO audit myself for free?

Yes. Search Console, PageSpeed Insights and Lighthouse are free. Screaming Frog (up to 500 URLs) and Ahrefs Webmaster Tools have free versions that suit small sites.

How long does a DIY SEO audit take?

For a site under about 100 pages, two to three hours using the steps above. The fixes take longer than the audit.

Should I fix every warning an audit tool shows?

No. Tools flag many minor items. Fix what blocks indexing, what's broken, and pages near page one first; many warnings barely matter.

Do I need to check backlinks in an audit?

Not in depth. The steps above usually matter more; earning links is its own job, covered in backlinks for a local business.

Different for you?

Keep learning

NextSEO audits that get results: tailor the audit to the siteHow to scope an SEO audit to your business: which checks matter for your kind of site, which generic checks to skip, and what a useful audit ends with.

Do it yourself

SEO checklist: 10 steps to rank higher with the site you haveAn SEO checklist for an existing website: 10 steps in priority order, the free Google tool for each, and how to tell when a step is done.

Ask us one question

One line is enough. We reply by email.

Sources

  1. Google Search Central: SEO Starter Guide
  2. Google Search Central: site: search operator
  3. Search Console Help: Page indexing report
  4. Google Search Central: Introduction to robots.txt
  5. Google Search Central: Redirects and Google Search
  6. Google Search Central: Understanding Core Web Vitals
  7. Google Search Central: Understanding page experience
  8. Google Search Central Blog: More on page experience in Search (April 2023)
  9. PageSpeed Insights: About
  10. Chrome for Developers: Lighthouse overview
  11. Google Search Central: Influencing title links
  12. Google Search Central: Link best practices
  13. Google Search Central: Debugging drops in Google Search traffic
  14. Screaming Frog: SEO Spider user guide, General
  15. Ahrefs: Ahrefs Webmaster Tools