SEO deliverables: what your provider should hand you
Short answer Expect work you can check, not just reports: a ranked audit with effort estimates, a plan matching searches to pages, a monthly log of every change, the live pages and profile updates themselves, and a short report from your own Search Console and call records. Tool health scores, long PDFs and link counts with no list prove nothing.
Want help applying this to your business? Talk it through on a free 30-minute call.
Book a callSEO deliverables checklist: what you should get
Six things. If your provider can't show you each one, you can't tell what you're paying for.
| Deliverable | When | A useful one | A useless one |
|---|---|---|---|
| Audit | First month | A short list of problems, ranked, each with the page, why it matters, the effort and who fixes it | A 90-page tool export where every warning looks equally urgent |
| Search and page plan | First month, then quarterly | The searches you want to win, each matched to one page that exists or will be written | A spreadsheet of 500 keywords with search volumes and no pages |
| Change log | Every month | Date, page address, what changed, why | "Optimized on-page elements" |
| The work itself | Every month | New or rewritten pages live on your site, profile updates, fixes you can see | Drafts that never get published |
| Results report | Every month | Calls, forms and bookings from search, plus clicks on searches without your name, from your own accounts | Ranking screenshots and a tool score |
| Link list | Only if they build links | Every link: the page it's on and how it was earned | "30 backlinks built" with no list |
Google's own hiring checklist asks for this openly. One of its questions for any SEO: "Will you share with me all the changes you make to my site, and provide detailed information about your recommendations and the reasoning behind them?" (Google Search Central)
What a useful SEO audit looks like
It says what to fix first, what each fix should do, and how much work it is. Google's definition:
"An SEO audit should be about giving you realistic estimates of improvement, and an estimate of the work involved." (Google Search Central)
A good audit for a small service business fits on a few pages:
- Ranked by payoff. Problems that stop pages from showing at all come first (a service page Google can't find, a site that blocks search engines). Small polish comes last.
- Tied to pages. Each item names the exact page address, so you or your web person can act on it without guessing.
- Plain words. Each technical term is explained once. Google's advice: "Ask for explanations if something is unclear" (Google Search Central).
- Backed by Google's own docs. Google suggests asking: "Do they cite official Google documentation as supporting evidence for their recommendations?" (Google Search Central)
Audit items Google says don't matter
Audit tools flag hundreds of issues. Several common ones are things Google has said it ignores. If these lead the list, the audit was not written for you.
| Tool warning | What Google says |
|---|---|
| Missing meta keywords | "Google Search doesn't use the keywords meta tag." (SEO Starter Guide) |
| Page too short | There is "no magical word count target, minimum or maximum" (same guide) |
| Headings out of order | From Google Search's view, "it doesn't matter if you're using them out of order" (same guide) |
| Duplicate content | Content reachable at several addresses is "not something that will cause a manual action" (same guide) |
| Low "E-E-A-T score" | Asked whether E-E-A-T is a ranking factor: "No, it's not." (same guide) |
| Speed score below 100 | "trying to get a perfect score just for SEO reasons may not be the best use of your time" (Google page experience) |
The same goes for "SEO health" or "authority" scores. Google: "Third-party tools don't have access to our internal ranking data." (Google Search Central)
The change log: the deliverable most worth asking for
A change log is a plain list of every edit made to your site and listings, with dates. It does two jobs:
- It proves the work happened. You can open each page and see it.
- It lets you match changes to results. Google says to "wait a few weeks to assess whether your work had beneficial effects" (SEO Starter Guide). With dates, you can check whether calls and clicks moved after a change, or didn't.
What one month can look like:
| Date | Page or listing | Change | Why |
|---|---|---|---|
| Nov 3 | /water-heater-repair/ | Rewrote the page: prices, service area, photos of real jobs | Getting seen but rarely clicked |
| Nov 10 | Google Business Profile | Added two missing services and 12 job photos | Services list didn't match the website |
| Nov 18 | /tankless-installation/ | New page | People search for it; no page existed |
Google is blunt about providers who won't share this: "Be careful if a company is secretive or won't clearly explain what they intend to do." (Google Search Central)
The monthly SEO report: one page, from your own accounts
The report should answer "did search bring customers this month?" The numbers to put on it, in order, are in is my SEO working?. Two rules make any report trustworthy:
- Your accounts, not theirs. Numbers should come from your Search Console, your Google Business Profile and your call log or booking form, so you can open them yourself. Google calls Search Console its "first-party tool" with data "directly from Google Search itself" (Google Search Central). Stay the owner of every account; see leaving your agency without losing it.
- A decision at the end. What worked, what didn't, what changes next month.
For the full lead-to-revenue report across ads and SEO, see the report to ask for.
Signs an SEO deliverable is useless
| You get | Ask |
|---|---|
| A health score of 92/100 | Which items did you fix, and on which pages? |
| "We optimized 40 pages" | Send the addresses and what changed on each |
| "#1 for 25 keywords" | How many clicks did those searches bring, per Search Console? |
| "Built 30 backlinks" | Send the list of pages the links are on |
| The same report as last month with new numbers | What did you change, and what's next? |
| A dashboard only they can log in to | Show me the same numbers in my own account |
The link list matters more than it sounds. Paying for links to rank, or getting them from automated services, is link spam under Google's rules (Google spam policies), and "you are responsible for the actions of any companies you hire" (Google Search Central). What good links look like: backlinks for a local business.
Example
Illustrative cases. Prices are invented for the example.
A landscaper with a monthly PDF
He pays $900 a month and gets a 30-page PDF: a site score, 200 keyword positions, a traffic chart. He asks for the change log. The provider sends four lines for three months. He sets a rule: no change log, no invoice.
A dental practice gets an audit
The first audit lists 340 warnings, led by meta keywords and heading order. She asks for the top ten, ranked, with effort. The new list starts with two treatment pages Google hadn't indexed. Those get fixed in week one.
A bookkeeper checks a "30 backlinks" claim
She asks for the list. Twenty-two are profiles on directories she's never heard of. She asks the provider to stop, and keeps the list in case a problem shows up later.
FAQ
What should be in an SEO proposal?
The work, counted (pages, profile updates, fixes), each deliverable's timing, and how results are measured. Google: "No one can guarantee a #1 ranking on Google." (Google Search Central)
How often should I get an SEO report?
Monthly is enough for a small business. Search changes take weeks to show, so a weekly report mostly shows noise.
Is a video walkthrough better than a written report?
It can be easier to follow. Keep the written change log anyway: a video can't be searched or checked line by line six months later.
Should rankings be in the report at all?
As a side note. Google weighs the searcher's "location and settings" (Google Search), so a screenshot shows one person's view. Clicks, calls and bookings matter more.
Different for you?
- Still choosing a provider: hiring an SEO company.
- Want to read the numbers yourself: is my SEO working?
- Need one report across ads, SEO and referrals: the marketing report to ask for.
- Planning to switch providers: leaving your agency without losing your accounts.
- Want the work done and every change shown to you: SEO & GEO Agent.