Modern SEO: what still works in the AI era, and what stopped
Short answer Most basics still pay off: pages that answer customers, clear titles, internal links, earned links and a complete Business Profile. Google says its AI answers run on its core ranking systems. What stopped: keyword stuffing, meta keywords, keyword domains, word-count targets, bought links, copied town pages, mass-produced posts and FAQ markup for extra space.
Want help applying this to your business? Talk it through on a free 30-minute call.
Book a callWhat still works in SEO, and what stopped?
Most of the old playbook still works, because Google's AI answers sit on top of its normal search:
"The best practices for SEO continue to be relevant because our generative AI features on Google Search are rooted in our core Search ranking and quality systems." (Google Search Central: Optimizing for generative AI features)
What stopped is mostly shortcuts: tricks that made a page look relevant instead of being useful. The scorecard, from Google's documentation as of November 2026 and one Pew Research study:
| Tactic | Status |
|---|---|
| Service pages that answer real customer questions | Works, and counts more than before |
| Clear, specific page titles | Works |
| Links between your own pages | Works |
| Links other sites give you on their own | Works |
| Pages Google can crawl and index | Works, and AI answers require it |
| A complete Google Business Profile | Works, and helps in AI answers |
| Fast pages that work on phones | Works, but won't win alone |
| Keyword research | Changed: one strong page per service, not per phrasing |
| Meta descriptions | Changed: for clicks, not rankings |
| Schema markup | Changed: for rich results; AI answers don't need it |
| Blogging | Changed: first-hand posts only |
| Updating old pages | Changed: real updates, not new dates |
| Tracking rankings | Changed: count calls and bookings too |
| Keyword stuffing and town-name lists | Stopped; spam |
| Meta keywords tag | Stopped |
| Keywords in the domain name | Stopped |
| Word count targets | Never worked |
| Bought links, link swaps, mass directory listings | Stopped; spam |
| One page copied for each town | Stopped; spam |
| Buying an old domain to borrow its rankings | Stopped; spam |
| Mass-produced posts, AI-written or not | Stopped; spam |
| FAQ and How-to markup for extra space in results | Stopped; Google removed both |
The Google pages behind this list set no separate rules for Canada, so the scorecard holds for US and Canadian sites alike.
Which SEO tactics still work with AI search?
The ones that make a page useful and easy for Google to read. Google's AI Overviews and AI Mode pull pages from the same index as the blue links, so this work now pays in both places.
- Pages that answer what customers ask. Price ranges, what's included, how long it takes, where you work, photos of real jobs. Google says content people find "unique, compelling, and useful" will likely matter more for its AI search than anything else in its guide (Optimizing for generative AI features).
- Clear titles. Google builds a result's headline partly from your page's title tag. Its rule: "a good title is unique to the page, clear and concise, and accurately describes the contents of the page" (SEO Starter Guide). "Water heater replacement in Mesa | Smith Plumbing" beats "Home".
- Internal links. Links between your own pages help people and Google find them: "Every page you care about should have a link from at least one other page on your site." (Link best practices for Google)
- Links you earn. Links still count. PageRank, Google's link-based system from launch day, "continues to be part of our core ranking systems" (A guide to Google Search ranking systems). Earned means a supplier, a trade association or a local paper links to you because you're worth it. See backlinks for a local business.
- Pages Google can index. To appear in AI Overviews or AI Mode, a page "must be indexed and eligible to be shown in Google Search with a snippet" (Optimizing for generative AI features). See website not showing on Google.
- Your Google Business Profile. Google says Business Profiles can help your services "be visible in both AI responses and other Google Search results" (Optimizing for generative AI features). Keep hours, services and photos current. See how to rank higher on Google Maps.
- Speed and phone-friendly pages. Worth fixing, not worth obsessing over. "Core Web Vitals are used by our ranking systems", Google says, but good scores don't "guarantee that your pages will rank at the top" (Understanding page experience). See Core Web Vitals.
Which old SEO tactics changed?
Still worth doing, but for a different reason or in a different way.
- Keyword research. Find the words customers use, then cover them on one strong page per service. Google's AI "can understand synonyms and general meanings", so you needn't chase every longer variation of a search, the "long-tail" keywords (Optimizing for generative AI features). A separate page for each variation, made mainly to sway results, breaks its scaled content abuse policy. See keyword research for a local business.
- Meta descriptions. Write them to win the click, not to rank. Google builds most snippets from your page text and uses the description tag only sometimes (Control your snippets). Back in 2009 it said: "we still don't use the description meta tag in our ranking." (Google Search Central Blog, 2009)
- Schema markup. Useful for rich results, not a pass into AI answers. Google: "Structured data isn't required for generative AI search, and there's no special schema.org markup you need to add." It still recommends markup because it helps pages qualify for rich results (Optimizing for generative AI features). See local business schema markup.
- Blogging. Generic tip posts lost value. Google calls a piece like "7 Tips for First-Time Homebuyers" commodity content that "typically adds little unique insight for readers", and favors first-hand experience. It adds that "a high quantity of pages doesn't make a website higher quality or more relevant to users" (Optimizing for generative AI features). See do blogs help SEO?
- Refreshing old pages. Update when facts change: prices, services, rules. New dates on unchanged pages don't count. Google's self-check asks whether you're "changing the date of pages to make them seem fresh when the content has not substantially changed", and says mass adding or deleting pages to look fresh won't help: "(No, it won't)" (Creating helpful content). See content decay.
- Rank tracking. Ranking well sends fewer visitors when an AI summary shows. In Pew Research's study of 900 US adults' March 2025 searches, people clicked a result on 8% of visits to results pages with an AI summary, against 15% without one. Rankings still matter, but count calls, forms and bookings. See is my SEO working?
Which SEO tactics stopped working?
These either never helped or now count as spam. Google says sites that break its spam policies "may rank lower in results or not appear in results at all" (Spam policies).
| Tactic | Verdict | Google's words |
|---|---|---|
| Keyword stuffing, including blocks of town names | Spam | Its examples include "Blocks of text that list cities and regions that a web page is trying to rank for" (Spam policies) |
| Meta keywords tag | Ignored | "Google Search doesn't use the keywords meta tag." (SEO Starter Guide) |
| Keywords in the domain name | Almost no effect | Domain keywords "alone have hardly any effect beyond appearing in breadcrumbs" (SEO Starter Guide) |
| Word count targets | Never a factor | Asked if it prefers a word count: "(No, we don't.)" (Creating helpful content) |
| Bought links, link swaps, low-quality directories, guest posts with keyword links | Link spam | When Google strips spammy links' effect, the benefit "cannot be regained" (Google Search spam updates) |
| One page copied for each town | Doorway abuse | "Having multiple domain names or pages targeted at specific regions or cities that funnel users to one page" (Spam policies) |
| Mass-produced posts | Scaled content abuse | Unoriginal pages at volume break the rule "no matter how it's created" (Spam policies) |
| Buying an old domain to borrow its rankings | Expired domain abuse | Reusing one "primarily to manipulate search rankings" (Spam policies) |
| FAQ and How-to markup for extra space in results | Feature removed | How-to results ended in September 2023; FAQ results left Google Search on May 7, 2026 (Google Search Central) |
A real page for a town where you work, with its own jobs and details, isn't a doorway: see city pages for service areas. Which directory listings are still worth having is a separate question: see local citations and directories. On keywords, see keyword density and keyword domain names. On AI writing, see does Google penalize AI content?
Example
Illustrative cases with round numbers, not client results.
A roofer paying for 30 links a month (US dollars)
The $500-a-month package places links on sites that sell posts. That's link spam, and any lift can vanish for good. Better use of the money: three full service pages with photos and price ranges, plus asking two suppliers and the local builders' association to link to the site.
A Calgary furnace company offered a keyword domain (Canadian dollars)
An agency quotes C$3,000 to move the site from the company's own name to a domain like calgary-furnace-repair.ca. Google says domain keywords alone barely affect ranking. Better use of the money: keep the brand domain and add service pages with prices, photos and the areas served.
A dental clinic with FAQ markup on every page
The markup no longer shows anything in Google. No rush to strip it: when Google cut back FAQ results in 2023, it said unused structured data "does not cause problems for Search" (Changes to HowTo and FAQ rich results). The clinic keeps the questions on the page for patients and stops paying to mark up new ones.
FAQ
Is SEO still worth it with AI Overviews?
Yes, for most local businesses: Google's AI answers draw on its index and ranking. The click data and what to stop paying for are in is SEO dead because of AI?
Do clicks or time on page affect rankings?
Google says it uses "aggregated and anonymized interaction data to assess whether search results are relevant to queries" (How Search works). It doesn't name bounce rate or time on page, so make pages that answer the question rather than chasing those numbers.
Is E-E-A-T a ranking factor?
Not by itself. To that exact belief, Google's Starter Guide answers: "No, it's not." Showing who did the work still helps people trust you. See E-E-A-T for a small business.
How long until fixes show up?
Google says some changes take effect "in a few hours, others could take several months" (SEO Starter Guide). See how long SEO takes.
Different for you?
- Your traffic fell after a Google update: traffic dropped after a core update
- Search Console shows a manual action: Google manual action
- An agency sells "GEO" on top of SEO: is GEO worth it?
- You want the full list for a local business: local SEO checklist
- You'd rather have the work that still pays done for you: SEO & GEO Agent