Small business hiring process: find, hire and keep good people
Short answer Define the job and its pay, post it where your kind of worker looks, screen with the same questions and a short paid work test for everyone, check references, then make a written offer. Do the first-week paperwork on time, and plan the first 90 days so the person stays. Job post rules differ by state and province.
Want help applying this to your business? Talk it through on a free 30-minute call.
Book a callThe hiring process, step by step
Plan on three to six weeks for one hire with these eight steps. Don't skip step 1: you can't pick the right person for a job you haven't defined.
| Step | What you do | Output |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Define the job | List the 3–5 results the person must deliver in 90 days, the must-have skills, and the pay | One-page job brief |
| 2. Write the post | Turn the brief into a short ad with pay, hours, location and how to apply | Job post |
| 3. Find candidates | Ask your network, post on one or two job boards, and on your own site | 10–30 applicants |
| 4. Screen | Short phone call against your must-haves | 3–5 people to interview |
| 5. Interview and test | Same questions for everyone, scored; a short paid work test | 1–2 finalists |
| 6. Check | Call references; background check only if the job needs it | A clear choice |
| 7. Offer | Written offer: pay, start date, hours, probation, who they report to | Signed offer |
| 8. Onboard | First-week paperwork, a 30-60-90 day plan, weekly check-ins | A person who stays |
The rest of this guide covers each step, plus the rules that change by country, state and province.
Do I need an employee, or a contractor?
Hire an employee when you will direct how and when the work is done. That's the line tax agencies draw. The IRS says the key is "the extent of the right to direct and control the worker", judged by behavioral control, financial control and the type of relationship (IRS: Independent contractor or employee?). Canada's CRA applies its own test; check it before you treat anyone as self-employed.
If the work is a defined project (a website, a bookkeeping cleanup, an ad campaign), a contractor or agency is often simpler. Marketing agency alternatives compares those routes for marketing work, and scaling sales without hiring covers lead follow-up you can automate instead.
How do I write a job post that gets good applicants?
Lead with what the applicant needs to decide: pay, hours, location, and what a normal week looks like. Then list only true must-haves; every nice-to-have you add shrinks the pool.
A strong post has:
- A plain job title people search for ("Office manager", not "Chief of First Impressions").
- The pay or pay range.
- The schedule, location, and whether any of it is remote.
- 3–5 sentences on the actual work.
- Must-haves (license, driving record, years with a tool) kept separate from nice-to-haves.
- One clear way to apply, that works on a phone.
Words to keep out. The EEOC, the US body that enforces job discrimination law, says an ad can't show a preference for, or discourage, anyone based on a protected trait such as race, sex, religion, national origin, age or disability. Its examples: ads asking for "females" or "recent college graduates" (EEOC: Prohibited employment policies and practices). Describe the work, not the person.
Pay range rules (Canada). In British Columbia, every provincially regulated employer must put pay in a public job ad, since November 1, 2023. The law also says:
"An employer must not seek pay history information about an applicant for employment by any means, whether directly from the applicant or through a third party, unless the pay history information is publicly accessible." (British Columbia: Pay Transparency Act, s. 3)
In Ontario, since January 1, 2026, employers with 25 or more employees must state the expected pay (a range no wider than $50,000 a year), whether they use AI to screen applicants, and whether the job is an existing vacancy. They can't ask for Canadian experience, must tell every interviewed applicant within 45 days whether a decision was made, and must keep each post for 3 years (Ontario: ESA guide on job postings). The count is people, not full-time equivalents:
"The requirements for publicly advertised job postings do not apply to an employer that employs fewer than 25 employees on the day the publicly advertised job posting is posted." (Ontario: ESA guide)
Pay range rules (US). There is no federal rule; a number of states and cities have their own. Check your state labor department before you post.
Where do I find good candidates?
Start with people who already know your work: past applicants, customers, suppliers and your team's referrals. Then post on one or two big job boards, a trade or local board for skilled roles, and a careers page on your own site.
Don't rely on referrals alone. The EEOC warns that word-of-mouth hiring by a mostly one-group workforce can break the law if almost all new hires end up from that same group (EEOC: Prohibited employment policies and practices).
How should a small business interview candidates?
Use a structured interview: the same questions, in the same order, scored the same way. The US Office of Personnel Management describes it like this:
"All candidates are asked the same predetermined questions in the same order." (OPM: Structured interviews)
How to run one:
- Write 6–8 questions tied to the 90-day results in your job brief. Ask about real past situations: "Tell me about a time a customer was angry about a bill. What did you do?"
- Write down what a strong, average and weak answer sounds like before the first interview.
- Score each answer 1–5 right after the interview, before you talk to anyone else about the candidate.
- Add a short paid work test that mirrors the job: answer three sample customer emails, quote a sample job, build one spreadsheet.
Pay for the test: it respects the candidate's time and keeps it clear that it's a test, not free labour.
What can't I ask in an interview?
Ask only what tells you whether the person can do the job. The EEOC says pre-hire questions should be limited to those "essential for determining if a person is qualified for the job" and that employers "are explicitly prohibited from making pre-offer inquiries about disability" (EEOC: Prohibited employment policies and practices).
| Don't ask | Ask instead |
|---|---|
| "How old are you?" | "Are you at least 18?" (only if the job requires it) |
| "Do you have kids?" or "Are you planning a family?" | "This job starts at 7 a.m. Can you work that schedule?" |
| "Where are you originally from?" | "Are you legally allowed to work here?" |
| "Do you have any health problems?" | "Can you lift 50 pounds, with or without an accommodation?" |
On the last row, the EEOC's guidance says an employer "may ask whether applicants can perform any or all job functions" (EEOC: Preemployment disability-related questions). Medical questions and exams wait until after a conditional job offer, and then must apply to everyone in the same job.
Who the federal law covers depends on headcount. The equal pay law applies from one employee; most other federal discrimination laws from 15; the age law from 20 (EEOC: Do the federal laws apply to my business?). State and local laws often cover smaller employers.
In Canada, most private businesses fall under their provincial or territorial human rights law. The federal commission handles only federally regulated employers such as banks, airlines and telecom; a private store or restaurant goes to the provincial agency (Canadian Human Rights Commission).
Do I need a background check?
Only if the job needs it, such as handling money, driving, or working in clients' homes. Call two references either way; ask what the person was like to manage and whether they would rehire them.
In the US, if you buy a check from a background check company, the Fair Credit Reporting Act applies. The FTC says you must tell the applicant in writing, in a notice that is "in a stand-alone format" and not part of the application, and get their written permission. If the report leads you to turn an applicant down, first send them a copy of it and a summary of their rights, and after rejecting them, tell them how to dispute it (FTC: Background checks).
Criminal history. The EEOC says "some states prohibit employers from even asking about criminal history until later in the hiring process", often called "ban the box". An arrest alone isn't a reason to reject someone (EEOC: Pre-employment inquiries and arrest and conviction records). Check your state and city rules before the application asks.
Making the offer and the first-week paperwork
Put the offer in writing: title, pay, hours, start date, any probation period, and who they report to. Then do the paperwork on time.
| Country | What | When |
|---|---|---|
| US | Employer ID number (EIN), before your first hire | Before payroll (SBA) |
| US | Form I-9, Section 1, filled in by the employee | By the first day of work (USCIS M-274) |
| US | Form I-9, Section 2, you check their documents | "Within 3 business days of the date of hire" (USCIS) |
| US | Form W-4 for tax withholding | When they start work (IRS: Hiring employees) |
| US | Report the new hire to your state | Within 20 days; some states require it sooner (ACF) |
| US | Workers' compensation insurance | Required, through a carrier, self-insurance or a state program (SBA) |
| Canada | Payroll program account with the CRA | Before your first remittance is due (CRA T4001) |
| Canada | Social insurance number (SIN) | "Within 3 days of when they start to work for you" (CRA) |
| Canada | Federal and provincial TD1 forms | Before you pay them (CRA T4001) |
Onboarding: what should the first 90 days look like?
Plan it before day one, so the new hire knows what good work looks like from the start.
- Day 1: paperwork done, tools and logins ready, lunch with the team, one small task they can finish.
- Week 1: shadow the person or owner who did the job before; write down every question.
- Day 30: handles the routine work alone; you review it together weekly.
- Day 60: owns one of the 90-day results from the job brief.
- Day 90: review against the brief. Keep, coach, or let go while it's still early.
How do I keep good employees?
Keep the promises made in the hiring process, and check in before people decide to leave.
- Pay: review it at least once a year, and check what your job post would need to offer today.
- Feedback: a 15-minute weekly one-on-one catches problems while they're small.
- Growth: show the next step (a new skill, a raise tied to a result, a lead role) even in a team of five.
- Ask: "What would make you leave?" is a fair question in a one-on-one. The answer is cheaper than a new hire.
Example
A plumbing company in Ohio hires its first office manager
The owner writes a one-page brief: book jobs, chase invoices, and answer reviews within 90 days, at $22 to $26 an hour. The post lists pay and hours. 24 people apply; 5 get a phone screen, 3 get the same 7 questions and a 1-hour paid test (book three sample calls into the calendar). She calls two references, makes a written offer, completes the I-9 within three business days and reports the hire to the state.
A Toronto marketing studio with 30 staff hires a designer
Because it has 25 or more employees, the post shows a range of $60,000 to $75,000, and says the job is an existing vacancy. It doesn't use AI to screen, so it needs no AI statement. No Canadian-experience requirement appears. Each of the four people interviewed hears back within 45 days, and the studio saves a copy of the post for 3 years.
FAQ
How long should hiring take for a small business?
Plan on three to six weeks from post to offer for most roles. Set interview dates before you post so a long gap doesn't cost you the best applicant.
Should I put the salary in the job post?
Yes, unless you have a reason not to. It saves time on both sides, and in British Columbia (all employers) and Ontario (25 or more employees) it's the law.
Can I use AI to screen applicants?
You can, but you're still responsible for a fair result. In Ontario, employers with 25 or more employees must say in the post that AI is used to screen, assess or select applicants.
Is a paid work test worth it?
For most roles, yes. A short task that mirrors the real job shows more than an interview answer, and paying for it keeps it fair to the candidate.
What is a probation period?
A set early period, often the first 90 days, when you both decide whether the job fits. What it changes legally depends on your state or province and on the employment contract.
Different for you?
- You're hiring for marketing and unsure it needs a full-time person: compare options in marketing agency alternatives or see the work an AI agent can take on at /conversion/.
- You're hiring to answer leads faster: read scaling sales without hiring first.
- You're hiring an outside SEO firm, not an employee: use hiring an SEO company.
- You're building a team mixing people and AI tools: see AI marketing strategy.