David Schneider's SEO journey: from math major to agency CEO
Short answer Dave Schneider was never a professor. He studied math at Harvard, worked as a business analyst at Capital One, sold links on a travel blog, co-founded the outreach tool Ninja Outreach, sold it in 2018, and started the link building agency Shortlist. Owners can learn three things: paid links need a label, link quality is checkable, and contract terms change.
Want help applying this to your business? Talk it through on a free 30-minute call.
Book a callWho is David Schneider?
Dave Schneider is the CEO of Shortlist, an SEO and link building agency, and a co-founder of Ninja Outreach, a tool for finding bloggers and influencers and emailing them. His path ran from math to finance to blogging to software to an agency. There was no academic career in it.
| Step | What he did | Source |
|---|---|---|
| School | Math major at Harvard | SaaS Club podcast |
| First job | About two years as a business analyst at Capital One | SaaS Club; Niche Pursuits podcast |
| Next two years | Backpacked with his girlfriend, ran a travel blog, did some link selling | SaaS Club; Niche Pursuits |
| Mid-2014 to 2018 | Co-founded and ran Ninja Outreach, then sold it in 2018 | Niche Pursuits; SaaS Club |
| 2018 to now | Started Shortlist, a link building and SEO agency | Shortlist About page and blog |
On the SaaS Club podcast he puts it plainly: "I'm at Harvard, I'm a college student, I'm a math major." The corporate job came next; he told Niche Pursuits it was a business analyst role in Washington, DC, and he left it to travel.
How did a travel blog turn into an SEO business?
Through link selling. While traveling, he sold links on the blog, which in his telling was an early opportunity in that market (Niche Pursuits podcast). Companies paid because a link from another site can help a page rank on Google. A backlink is simply a link from someone else's site to yours.
That income did not last. He told Niche Pursuits that in early 2014 Google made algorithm changes that penalized that whole market, and it imploded. That pushed him toward software.
This is the lesson most owners need from his story. Google's rules say paying for links meant to raise rankings is spam:
"Buying or selling links for ranking purposes." (Google Search Central: Spam policies, listed as an example of link spam)
Google also says paid links are fine when they are labeled:
"It's not a violation of our policies to have such links as long as they are qualified with a rel="nofollow" or rel="sponsored" attribute value..." (Google Search Central: Spam policies)
rel="sponsored" is a short tag in the link's code that tells Google "this was paid for," so the link passes no ranking credit. If you pay for a link and the seller won't add it, the purchase is the risky kind. More in buying backlinks and, if a site offers to pay you, selling backlinks.
How did Ninja Outreach lead to Shortlist?
Shortlist began as a side effect. On Shortlist's blog, Dave writes:
"Shortlist wasn't part of some grand plan. In fact, it basically happened by accident." (Shortlist blog, December 2023)
While growing Ninja Outreach with SEO and content, he had built a team of writers, SEOs, designers and developers, and decided to sell that work as a service. The About page says he started Shortlist in 2018 after exiting a software business he had bootstrapped for over four years. His first hire came through Upwork from North Macedonia, where the company later opened an office. By the December 2023 post, he wrote that the agency consistently did over $100,000 a month and had "hit a ceiling," with a plan to rebrand and focus on agency clients.
What can a business owner learn from him?
Three things, each useful when you hire anyone to do SEO.
1. Link quality can be checked, so ask how
He says Shortlist stood out by setting minimum standards for every site it placed links on:
"We focused on minimum Domain Authorities and Organic Traffic, as well as standards for Spam Score, Trust Flow, Citation Flow and more." (Shortlist blog)
Those are scores from SEO tools, not from Google. Domain Authority and Spam Score come from Moz; Trust Flow and Citation Flow come from Majestic. Organic traffic is the visitors a site gets from search. None is perfect, but a provider who names its minimums is easier to hold to account than one who just promises "high-quality links." Ask for the list of sites before you pay. See hiring an SEO company for more questions.
2. Contract terms change, so read today's version
In 2023 Dave described his agency's terms as "No longterm contracts. No onboarding fees. Cancel any time." (Shortlist blog). Shortlist's home page in November 2026 lists "6-12 month commitments" and a "6-month minimum commitment," and the fine print of its results guarantee asks for 12 months while its FAQ says six. Neither is wrong; agencies change their model. The point for you: a podcast, a founder story or an old blog post is not the contract. See marketing agency contract terms.
3. SEO is slow, and good agencies say so
Shortlist's own home page explains its minimum this way: "SEO takes time. Anyone promising results in 30 days is lying." Plan your budget for months, not weeks.
Example
A plumber offered "DA 50 links" for $300 each
He asks for the site list and the traffic of each site. Two of five sites get almost no search visitors. He drops those, and asks that any paid placement carry rel="sponsored". Without the label, he walks away.
A dental office comparing two SEO agencies
Agency A offers month to month. Agency B wants six months. The owner reads both contracts, not their websites, and checks the notice period, who owns the content and what happens to links if she leaves.
FAQ
Was David Schneider a professor?
No source shows that. His own interviews describe Harvard as a math student, then a business analyst job at Capital One, then travel blogging.
Does Dave Schneider still run Ninja Outreach?
No. He sold it in 2018 and said on the SaaS Club podcast that he is no longer involved. He is CEO of Shortlist.
Is selling links on my blog allowed?
Yes, if each paid link carries rel="sponsored" or rel="nofollow". Without that label, Google treats it as link spam.
Are Domain Authority and Trust Flow Google scores?
No. They are third-party tool scores from Moz and Majestic. They help you compare sites quickly, but they are estimates.
Different for you?
- A site offers to pay you for a link: see selling backlinks.
- You're deciding whether to build links yourself: see link building: DIY or hire a service.
- You want SEO run for you without buying links: see the SEO agent.