Top SEO experts: who to follow and what they teach
Short answer Start with Google's own Search Central team, then one local search expert (Joy Hawkins or Darren Shaw), one news source (Barry Schwartz) and one weekly newsletter (Aleyda Solis's SEOFOMO). That covers the rules, local rankings, changes and AI search. Trust experts who show data and never promise rankings.
Want help applying this to your business? Talk it through on a free 30-minute call.
Book a callWho are the top SEO experts to follow?
There's no official ranking. The useful test is simpler: does this person teach something you can check and use? By that test, the list below covers what a small business owner needs: Google's rules, local rankings, news, and how AI search is changing clicks.
| Expert or source | Best for | Free way to follow |
|---|---|---|
| Google Search Central team (John Mueller, Martin Splitt, Gary Illyes) | What Google itself says | Search Central Blog; *Search Off the Record* podcast |
| Joy Hawkins (Sterling Sky) | Google Business Profile and local rankings | Local Search Forum |
| Darren Shaw (Whitespark) | What moves the map results | Yearly Local Search Ranking Factors report |
| Barry Schwartz | Daily search news | Search Engine Roundtable |
| Aleyda Solis (Orainti) | A weekly digest; learning SEO from zero | SEOFOMO newsletter; LearningSEO.io |
| Lily Ray (Amsive) | Trust signals (E-E-A-T) and AI search | Her site, talks and articles |
| Marie Haynes | Google updates and AI search | *Search & AI News You Can Use* newsletter |
| Rand Fishkin (SparkToro) | Where clicks really go | SparkToro blog and studies |
| Cyrus Shepard (Zyppy) | Experiments on what helps rankings | Zyppy Signal newsletter |
| Kevin Indig | SEO and AI search research | Growth Memo (weekly) |
You don't need all ten. Pick three: Google, one local expert, one digest.
Google's own experts come first
Google publishes its rules and explains them in public. That makes its Search Central team the primary source every other expert interprets.
- Search Off the Record is Google's podcast. Google describes it this way:
"Search Off the Record is a podcast show that takes you behind the scenes of Google Search and its inner workings." (Google Search Central)
Its hosts are Gary Illyes, Lizzi Sassman, Martin Splitt and John Mueller, Google's Search Relations Lead (same page).
- The Search Central Blog announces changes. In October 2026 it added curated YouTube playlists for Search fundamentals and technical SEO, a free course for beginners (Search Central Blog).
- One name changed. On August 1, 2025, Search Engine Roundtable reported that Danny Sullivan had left the Search Liaison role for other work on Google's Search team; updates now come through Search Central's accounts on X and LinkedIn and Google's blog (Search Engine Roundtable). Old articles quoting "the Search Liaison" may be out of date.
Google also says many owners can do SEO alone:
"If you run a small local business, you can probably do much of the work yourself." (Google Search Central: Do you need an SEO?)
Local SEO experts for a service business
If your customers find you on Google Maps, these two matter more than any famous generalist.
Joy Hawkins founded Sterling Sky in 2017, with offices in Uxbridge, Ontario and Delaware. Her team runs the Local Search Forum, a forum for business owners as well as consultants, and she is one of four staff listed as Google Business Profile (formerly Google My Business) Product Experts (Sterling Sky).
Darren Shaw runs Whitespark's Local Search Ranking Factors survey, started by David Mihm in 2008 and taken over by Shaw in 2017. The 2026 edition, published November 6, 2025, surveyed 47 local search experts (Whitespark). Its top-rated factors for the map results:
- Primary Google Business Profile category.
- How close your address is to the person searching.
- Keywords in your business name on the profile.
The report says reviews and how people interact with your listing are gaining weight (same source). It's an expert survey, not Google data, so treat it as informed opinion. Our local SEO checklist turns it into steps.
News and weekly digests
You can't read everything. One news source and one digest keep you current in minutes a week.
- Barry Schwartz founded Search Engine Roundtable and is News Editor of Search Engine Land (Search Engine Roundtable author page). The site posts a daily recap of ranking swings and Google statements.
- Aleyda Solis founded Orainti, an SEO and AI search consultancy, in 2014. She curates two free roadmaps: LearningSEO.io and LearningAIsearch.com (Orainti). Her SEOFOMO newsletter goes out every Sunday to more than 46,000 subscribers (SEOFOMO).
For what to do when news breaks, see how to keep up with Google search changes.
Experts on trust, updates and AI search
These four help you understand why rankings move and where clicks are going.
- Lily Ray is VP, SEO & AI Search at Amsive and writes about E-E-A-T, Google's term for experience, expertise, authoritativeness and trust (lilyray.nyc). What it means for a small site: E-E-A-T for small business.
- Marie Haynes, a former veterinarian, consults on Google's algorithms and AI search and wrote *SEO in the Gemini Era* (Marie Haynes).
- Rand Fishkin, Moz's former co-founder and CEO, now runs SparkToro (SparkToro). His 2024 study, using Datos clickstream data, found 58.5% of US Google searches ended with no click, and only 360 of every 1,000 searches sent a click to the open web (SparkToro). The lesson: your Google Business Profile and the results page itself are now part of your website.
- Cyrus Shepard publishes experiments, such as disavowing every link to his own site, and a 2026 ranking factors chart from an expert survey (Zyppy). Kevin Indig, formerly at Shopify, G2 and Atlassian, sends weekly research on SEO and AI search (Growth Memo).
What about Neil Patel?
He's the most-searched name in SEO, and worth knowing why. Neil Patel co-founded the agency NP Digital in 2017, and its site also features his Ubersuggest and AnswerThePublic tools (NP Digital). His content is easy to read and good for basics. Just remember that much of it leads to his own tools and agency. That's true of most experts: Datos, behind Fishkin's click study, is a Semrush company. Knowing who sells what helps you weigh advice.
How to tell good SEO advice from bad
Good experts show their evidence and say what they don't know. Use Google's own red flags:
"No one can guarantee a #1 ranking on Google." (Google Search Central: Do you need an SEO?)
The same page warns against anyone who claims a "special relationship" with Google.
Also check the date. Plenty of "expert" posts still describe Google's "Search Generative Experience", the test that became AI Overviews, which began rolling out to everyone in the US on May 14, 2024 (Google). Core Web Vitals now measure loading, responsiveness and visual stability, with responsiveness measured by Interaction to Next Paint, or INP (Google Search Central).
When a Google update hits and experts disagree, Google's advice is the tiebreaker:
"Instead, focus on making changes that make sense for your users and are sustainable in the long term." (Google Search Central: core updates)
Example
A plumber with 15 minutes a week
A plumber in Calgary subscribes to SEOFOMO and skims the Local Search Forum. When a post says business name keywords help, he checks Whitespark's report, sees it's an expert opinion, and doesn't rename his listing to stuff keywords. He fixes his primary category instead.
A dental office after a traffic drop
A clinic's site loses half its visits in a month. The office manager checks Search Engine Roundtable, sees a core update was announced that week, and follows Google's core update page instead of the first "recovery" offer in her inbox.
FAQ
Who is the number one SEO expert?
No one. There is no official ranking. For Google's rules, the best source is Google's Search Central team; for local businesses, local specialists like Joy Hawkins and Darren Shaw.
Can I learn SEO for free from experts?
Yes. Google's SEO starter guide and YouTube playlists, Aleyda Solis's LearningSEO.io, and the newsletters above are free.
Should I hire a famous SEO expert?
Usually not. Well-known names mostly serve large brands. Hire for results in businesses like yours; see hiring an SEO company.
Is it worth following SEO experts on LinkedIn or X?
Yes, if you mute the noise. Follow Google Search Central and two or three experts above, and ignore posts with no data or date.
Different for you?
- You want a person to do the work: hiring an SEO company.
- You're worried AI answers will replace search: is SEO dead because of AI?
- A Google update just hit your site: Google search changes.
- You serve one area and want map rankings: local SEO checklist.
- You'd rather have the SEO done for you: SEO Agent.