Products SEO & GEO Agent Paid Ads Agent Website Agent Conversion Agent
How it works Pricing FAQ Blog Book a call

Matt Diggity's SEO strategy: data, diversification, integrity

Updated · 6 min read

Short answer Matt Diggity treats SEO as volatile and mostly unpredictable: he says 75 to 80 percent of his own ranking tests fail, so he runs many tests and spreads his bets across several businesses. For a small business, that means testing small changes, not depending on one page or channel, and judging SEO by what customers are worth over time.

Want help applying this to your business? Talk it through on a free 30-minute call.

Book a call

Matt Diggity's SEO strategy in three ideas

Matt Diggity is an SEO practitioner who, by his own account, has worked in SEO since 2009. In a 2019 podcast he listed his businesses: a blog on tested ranking methods (diggitymarketing.com), an agency that builds, buys and sells affiliate websites (LeadSpring), a backlink service (Authority Builders), a client agency (The Search Initiative) and a course (The Affiliate Lab).

His approach, in his own interview words:

IdeaWhat he saidWhat it means for an owner
Rankings swing, always"Volatility is like just the name of the game with SEO." (StatsDrone, 2023)Plan for drops; don't build the business on one ranking
Most ideas fail, so test many"75 to 80 percent of these hypotheses that I come up with single and single variable testing don't actually work." (StatsDrone, 2023)Change one thing at a time and keep only what moves results
Spread the risk"the value in diversity is just more fun, and safer" (Empire Flippers, 2019)Don't let one page, one keyword or one channel carry all your leads

A single-variable test changes one thing on a page (say, the title) and watches what happens, so you know what caused the change.

Why does he treat SEO as a numbers game?

Because no one controls the outcome of a single move. Diggity says his whole portfolio of sites collapsed in his first profitable year, and that most of his tests produce nothing. The value of testing, he says, is mostly saving time on tactics that don't work.

Google's own record backs the point. Its Search Status Dashboard lists three core updates in 2026 so far: March, May and November (the November one started November 10). A core update is a broad change to how Google ranks pages.

"Several times a year, Google makes significant, broad changes to our search algorithms and systems." (Google Search Central: core updates)

So the "numbers game" is not about publishing hundreds of pages. It is about taking many small, measured shots, so one failure or one update doesn't sink you.

How a small business plays the numbers game

You don't need his lab of test sites. You need a short list of changes and the patience to measure each.

TestWhat to changeHow long to wait
Page titleRewrite the title of one service page to match how customers searchA few weeks
New service pageAdd a page for a service you sell but don't describe yetA few weeks to months
Content refreshUpdate prices, photos and FAQs on an old pageA few weeks
Internal linksLink from your busiest page to one that needs helpA few weeks

Google says results take time and vary:

"Some changes might take effect in a few hours, others could take several months. In general, you likely want to wait a few weeks to assess whether your work had beneficial effects in Google Search results." (Google Search Central: SEO Starter Guide)

Track each test in a simple sheet: date, page, change, and leads or calls before and after. Search Console shows clicks per page for free.

What does diversification mean for SEO?

For Diggity, diversity means several businesses that feed each other. For a local business, it means not letting one source carry all your leads:

  • Pages: several service and location pages ranking, not one.
  • Channels: search, your Google Business Profile, referrals, email and repeat customers.
  • Keywords: many specific searches ("water heater repair Tuesday"), not one big term.

How to measure your own risk and rebalance is covered in diversify traffic sources. Whether it's worth the effort at your size is in traffic diversification vs resilience.

Where his advice doesn't fit a small business

His portfolio model is built on many affiliate websites. He said in 2023 that, with AI, "I'm printing out websites right now." That suits a publisher who earns commissions. It doesn't suit a plumber or a dental office with one brand.

Copying it can break Google's rules. Google's spam policies list this as doorway abuse:

"Having multiple websites with slight variations to the URL and home page to maximize their reach for any specific query" (Google Search Central: spam policies)

The same policy covers several domains or near-identical pages aimed at different cities that all funnel to one page. Diversify with real pages and real channels, not copies of your site.

Customer lifetime value and integrity

Online summaries credit Diggity with a line that ranks customer lifetime and churn as an agency's top measure and a reputation for integrity second. We could not find it in his own posts or interviews, so treat it as a paraphrase, not his words. The idea still holds for any business.

Customer lifetime value (CLV) is what one customer spends with you over the whole relationship. Churn is the share of customers who leave in a period. If a lawn care client pays $1,200 a year and stays four years, one new client is worth $4,800, not $1,200. That tells you how much you can spend to win one. The math and how to raise it are in customer lifetime value.

Integrity, applied to SEO, starts with honest expectations. Google says it plainly:

"No one can guarantee a #1 ranking on Google." (Google Search Central: Do you need an SEO?)

Whether you hire help or sell it, a promise of first place is a warning sign. Google suggests an audit should give "realistic estimates of improvement" and the work involved. Questions to ask before you sign are in hiring an SEO company.

Example

A roofing company with one star page

One page brings 70% of its web leads. After a core update it drops from position 2 to 6 and leads halve. The owner adds pages for gutter repair and storm inspections and asks every customer for a Google review. Six months later no single page brings more than a third of leads.

A dental office testing titles

The office rewrites titles on five service pages, one every three weeks, and logs clicks in Search Console. Two titles lift clicks, three do nothing. It keeps the two and drops the rest, in line with Diggity's point that most tests fail.

A bookkeeper using lifetime value

A client pays $300 a month and stays three years on average: $10,800 over the relationship. Spending $1,000 on SEO and content to win one client a quarter is easy to justify.

FAQ

Who is Matt Diggity?

An SEO practitioner who runs a blog on tested ranking methods, client and affiliate agencies, a backlink service and an SEO course. He says he has done SEO since 2009.

Did Matt Diggity say SEO is a numbers game?

We found no interview where he uses that phrase. His recorded words are that volatility is "the name of the game" and that most of his tests fail, which is the same idea.

Should a small business build several websites to diversify?

No. Google treats several near-identical sites aimed at the same searches as doorway abuse. Diversify with more useful pages and more channels on one brand.

How long should I wait to judge an SEO change?

Google suggests waiting a few weeks; some changes take several months to show.

Different for you?

Keep learning

NextGotch SEO is now Rankability: what changed and whyWhere Gotch SEO and its academy went: the move to Rankability, what the training is now, what it costs, and what changed for old members.

Do it yourself

SEO onboarding checklist: what to hand over at kickoffWhat a new SEO client should share in week one: business facts, the right access level for each account, and the expectations to agree in writing.

Ask us one question

One line is enough. We reply by email.

Sources

  1. StatsDrone: Quitting your job for affiliate marketing & SEO with Matt Diggity (September 26, 2023)
  2. Empire Flippers Podcast, EFP 182: Mastering SEO With Matt Diggity (April 2019)
  3. Google Search Status Dashboard: Ranking incident history
  4. Google Search Central: Google Search's core updates and your website
  5. Google Search Central: SEO Starter Guide
  6. Google Search Central: Do you need an SEO?
  7. Google Search Central: Spam policies for Google web search