Directory submission: does it still help SEO?
Short answer Not as a way to build links. Google's spam policy names low-quality directory links and automated link services as link spam, and its systems discard the credit those links pass. A handful of listings still pay off because customers, maps and AI assistants read them: Google, Apple, Bing, Yelp and your trade's main directory.
Want help applying this to your business? Talk it through on a free 30-minute call.
Book a callDoes directory submission still help SEO?
Not as link building. It helps only where the directory itself has an audience: people, maps or AI assistants that read it.
| Kind of listing | Helps your SEO? | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Google Business Profile, Apple Business, Bing Places | Yes | They are the listings in Google Maps, Apple Maps and Bing |
| Yelp, Facebook, your trade's main directory | Usually | Customers search and read them |
| Your chamber of commerce or trade association | Often | A real, local, hand-checked link |
| "Submit to 500 directories" packages | No | Google classes these links as spam |
| Directories that want a link back | No | That's a link exchange |
Google's local ranking help says prominence depends partly on "how many websites link to your business and how many reviews you have." Links count. Links from sites nobody visits don't.
Why bulk directory submission stopped working
It used to be Google's own advice. Its 2005 Webmaster Guidelines said:
"Submit your site to relevant directories such as the Open Directory Project and Yahoo!, as well as to other industry-specific expert sites." (Google Webmaster Guidelines, archived December 2005)
Then thousands of directories appeared that existed only to sell links. Google pushed back in stages:
| When | What Google did |
|---|---|
| April 24, 2012 | A webspam update aimed at "link schemes", affecting about 3.1% of English queries |
| 2017 | DMOZ, the directory Google had pointed to, closed (see DMOZ and Curlie) |
| December 14, 2022 | Its SpamBrain system began to "neutralize the impact of unnatural links" |
| Today | The spam policy names directory links outright |
The current policy defines link spam as links made "primarily for the purpose of manipulating search rankings" and lists, among its examples:
"Low-quality directory or bookmark site links"
"Using automated programs or services to create links to your site"
"Excessive link exchanges ("Link to me and I'll link to you")"
(Google Search Central: Spam policies)
So a bulk package fails in one of two ways. Most often the links simply count for nothing: Google's 2022 post says "any credit passed by these unnatural links are lost." In worse cases the same policy page warns that sites which break it "may rank lower in results or not appear in results at all."
Are paid directory listings allowed?
Yes, if the link is labelled. Google says buying links is fine when they don't pass ranking credit: "It's not a violation of our policies to have such links as long as they are qualified" with nofollow or sponsored. Its link guide asks sites to mark "advertisements or paid placements" as sponsored.
What that means for you: a paid listing on a directory your customers really use can be worth the money as advertising. Judge it by calls and visits, not by a promised ranking boost. If the seller says the link will lift your Google rankings, they are describing a link Google treats as spam.
Claims sellers make, checked
| Claim | What the source says |
|---|---|
| "Directories get you indexed faster" | Google's own routes are the URL Inspection tool in Search Console and a sitemap, which Google calls "an important way for Google to discover URLs on your site" |
| "High Domain Authority directories boost rankings" | Moz, which created the score: "Domain Authority is not a Google ranking factor and has no effect on the SERPs" |
| "More listings means more trust" | Google's policy counts low-quality directory links as spam, not trust |
| "Link to your service pages for deep links" | Fine on a real directory; it doesn't rescue a spam one. See deep linking |
How to tell if one directory is worth it
Ask four questions. Two or more "no" answers means skip it.
- Would a customer use it? Search your service and city. If the directory shows up, people find it.
- Does a person check listings? Real directories verify the business; spam ones accept anything instantly.
- Does it ask for nothing back? A required link to them is a link exchange.
- Would you list there if Google didn't exist? If the only reason is the link, it's the wrong reason.
The short list that passes for most local businesses, and how to keep your details matching on it, is in local citations and directories.
How to submit your business the right way
- Write your name, address, phone, website and hours once, exactly as on your Google profile. Paste that same version everywhere (NAP consistency).
- Use your real business name, with no added keywords like "Best Plumber Dallas".
- Link to the page that matches the category, such as your emergency repair page, not always the home page.
- Write a short description in plain words. Don't reuse it word for word across sites.
- Keep a sheet: directory, date, login, what you paid. Update every listing when you move or change number.
Already bought a package?
Usually do nothing. Google's disavow help says "most sites will not need to use this tool" and suggests it only if you have many spammy links and they "have caused a manual action, or likely will cause" one. Check Search Console's Manual actions report first. More in backlink audit.
Example
Illustrative cases, US and Canadian dollars as stated.
A landscaper offered 300 directories for $199 (US)
Asked for the list, the seller sends sites with no traffic that accept any business instantly. He skips it, claims Bing Places and Apple Business for free, and joins his state landscaping association's member directory.
A bookkeeper in Ottawa with a paid listing offer (CAD 400 a year)
A national accountants' directory sends her two inquiries a month, and the link is marked sponsored. She keeps it as advertising and tracks the inquiries, not expecting it to move her Google ranking.
A dentist who bought a link package in 2019
Search Console shows no manual action. She leaves the old links alone and spends her time on reviews and her Google profile.
FAQ
What is directory submission?
Adding your business or website to an online list of businesses, usually with a link back to your site. It was a common link-building tactic in the 2000s.
Is directory submission black hat?
Bulk, automated or link-exchange submission is, by Google's spam policy. Listing your business on a few directories customers actually use is not.
Do nofollow directory links help?
Not for rankings, as a rule. They can still bring customers and help maps and AI assistants confirm your details. See backlinks for a local business.
How many directories should a small business be on?
Google publishes no number. Start with the short list that passes the four questions above, and keep each one accurate.
Different for you?
- You want the list of listings that matter: local citations and directories.
- You need links that do count: backlinks for a local business.
- You worry old links are hurting you: backlink audit.
- Someone offers DMOZ submission: DMOZ and Curlie.
- You'd rather have listings handled: SEO & GEO Agent.