Unnatural Links: Spot, Remove and Disavow Them
Short answer Unnatural links are links made to push rankings: bought, swapped, automated or keyword-stuffed. If Search Console shows an unnatural links manual action, export your links, sort out the ones that break Google's link spam policy, ask owners to remove them, disavow only what stays, then request review with a log of every attempt.
Want help applying this to your business? Talk it through on a free 30-minute call.
Book a callWhat counts as an unnatural link
An unnatural link is one made to move rankings, not to help a reader. Google's spam policy calls this link spam: links created "primarily for the purpose of manipulating search rankings" (Google Search Central: Spam policies). A backlink is a link from another site to yours.
What Google lists, in plain words:
| Link | Example for a local business |
|---|---|
| Paid with money, goods or services | $50 per blog post with a link; a free cleaning for a review with a link |
| Excessive swaps | "Link to me and I'll link to you" partner pages |
| Made by software | A tool that posts your link on hundreds of sites |
| Required by contract | A web designer's "Designed by" link the client can't qualify |
| Keyword-rich anchors in guest posts, press releases or advertorials | "best emergency plumber Dallas" in an article you paid for |
| Directory and bookmark farms | 200 listings on sites nobody visits |
| Widget and footer links spread across many sites | A free calculator that carries a hidden link back |
| Forum comments and signatures stuffed with keywords | "Thanks! – Joe, roof repair Tampa" |
Paid links are allowed if labeled. Google says they break no policy "as long as they are qualified with a rel="nofollow" or rel="sponsored" attribute value" (same page). So a chamber of commerce sponsorship link is fine if it carries `rel="sponsored"`.
Anchor text is the clickable words of a link. One customer blog using your business name is natural. Fifty unrelated sites all using "cheap roof repair Tampa" is a pattern someone built. More in our anchor text guide.
Two manual actions: links to you, links from you
Search Console's Manual actions report names one of two link actions. They need different fixes.
| Report says | What Google found | Your fix |
|---|---|---|
| Unnatural links to your site | A pattern of manipulative links pointing at you | Get them removed; disavow the rest |
| Unnatural links from your site | Paid or swapped links on your own pages | Remove them or add `rel="sponsored"` or `rel="nofollow"` |
Expand the action to see its scope. A path like `example.com/blog/*` means some pages; "Affects all pages" means the whole site (Search Console Help: Manual actions report). No manual action and a green check? Most sites shouldn't touch the disavow tool at all; run a calm backlink audit instead.
Step by step: fix "unnatural links to your site"
1. Export your links
In Search Console, open Links. Export by site (Top linking sites, then Export) or by date (Export external links, then Latest links). Google's advice for a long list is to start with the sites linking to you most and links from the last few months (Search Console Help: Manual actions report).
2. Mark each linking site
Put the export in a spreadsheet. Add a column: Keep, Remove, or Ignore.
- Keep: customers, suppliers, local press, associations. Google warns: "Make sure that you don't disavow organic links to your site." (Search Console Help: Manual actions report)
- Remove: anything you, a past agency or a "link package" paid for or automated.
- Ignore: random scraper sites you never dealt with. Google says it can usually judge "which links to trust without additional guidance" (Search Console Help: Disavow links).
Ask your old SEO provider for its list of placements.
3. Ask site owners to remove them
Send one short email per site: your page, the URL holding the link, and a request to remove it or add `rel="nofollow"`. Google asks owners to "either remove the links or prevent them from passing PageRank" (Search Console Help: Manual actions report). PageRank is the ranking credit a link passes.
Keep a log. It becomes the proof in your request.
| Site | Link URL | Contacted | How | Follow-up | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| blogA.com | blogA.com/post-12 | Nov 2 | Contact form | Nov 12 | Removed |
| dirB.net | dirB.net/listing/88 | Nov 2 | Nov 12 | No reply → disavow |
4. Disavow only what stays
Disavowing tells Google to ignore a link. Google's test:
"You should disavow backlinks only if: You have a considerable number of spammy, artificial, or low-quality links pointing to your site, AND The links have caused a manual action, or likely will cause a manual action, on your site." (Search Console Help: Disavow links to your site)
The file: plain `.txt`, UTF-8 or 7-bit ASCII, one URL or `domain:example.com` per line, `#` for comments, up to 100,000 lines and 2MB. One list per property; a new upload replaces the old one. It doesn't work on Domain properties, so use a URL-prefix property, one for http and one for https if you have both (same page).
Use `domain:` when a site links to you many times. Don't upload your whole export:
"Blindly adding all backlinks to the disavow file is not considered a good-faith effort, and will not be enough to make your reconsideration request successful." (Search Console Help: Manual actions report)
5. Request review
In the Manual actions report, click Request Review. Google asks link cases to "Include documentation about the links you've had removed and an explanation of any links you were unable to remove" (same page). A request that works covers three things:
- The cause. "A former agency bought guest posts with keyword anchors from 2023 to 2025."
- What you did. "We contacted 60 sites, 38 removed the link, we disavowed 22 domains."
- The proof. A link to your log (a shared spreadsheet) and the disavow file contents.
Then wait. Google says most reviews take "several days or weeks", and link-related ones "may take longer than usual." Don't resubmit while one is open (same page).
Step by step: fix "unnatural links from your site"
This one is about links you placed. Typical causes: you sold a "sponsored post" with a followed link, joined a swap circle, or run a partner page full of trades.
- Find every paid or swapped link on your site. Search your blog for words like "sponsored", "partner" or "guest post".
- Remove each one, or add `rel="sponsored"` (paid) or `rel="nofollow"`. Google also accepts sending them through a page blocked by robots.txt.
- Request review with examples of what you removed and what you added (Search Console Help: Manual actions report).
For links in comments or forum posts users write, Google recommends `rel="ugc"` (Google Search Central: Qualify your outbound links).
If the request is rejected
Google's own warnings point to three likely gaps: links you could have removed but only disavowed, a log too thin to show effort, or a pattern you missed, like a second batch of directory links. Close the gap, update the log and the file, then send a new request.
What to expect after it's lifted
Lifting the action doesn't bring back the boost those links gave. Google says of spammy links its systems remove:
"Any potential ranking benefits generated by those links cannot be regained." (Google Search Central: Google Search's spam updates and your site)
So traffic may return below the old peak. Growth from here comes from links that follow the rules. Our black hat SEO risks guide covers why bought links rarely pay.
Example
A roofer with a "500 links for $299" package
Report: unnatural links to your site, affects all pages. Export shows 120 directory and blog domains with the same keyword anchor. The owner emails all 120, gets 30 removed, disavows 90 domains, and requests review with the log. It's lifted after about five weeks. Calls from search come back, but lower than the peak.
A salon blog that sold guest posts
Report: unnatural links from your site. The blog carried 40 paid posts with followed links out. The owner adds `rel="sponsored"` to all 40 and requests review. Lifted in about two weeks.
A dentist with spam links and no manual action
A tool flags 400 "toxic" links from sites the office never dealt with. The Manual actions report shows a green check. No disavow needed; Google typically ignores such links.
FAQ
Can a competitor give me unnatural links?
Rarely. Google "works very hard to make sure that actions on third-party sites do not negatively affect a website."
Do I have to remove links before disavowing?
For a manual action, yes, where you can. Google warns that disavowing without trying to remove links "might lead to rejection of your request."
How long does the disavow file take to work?
Google says "it can take a few weeks" after upload, as it recrawls the pages.
Are nofollow links unnatural?
No. Google says paid links marked `nofollow` or `sponsored` don't violate its link spam policy.
Different for you?
- You don't know yet whether you have a manual action: Google manual action guide.
- The penalty also covers thin or spammy pages: SEO penalty removal.
- No manual action, just a scary "toxic" score: backlink audit.
- You want the cleanup and request handled: SEO & GEO Agent.