Sitewide Links: When Footer and Sidebar Links Are Risky
Short answer A footer or sidebar link is risky when it exists to move rankings: it was paid for or traded, uses a keyword as its anchor, appears on many unrelated sites at once, or was required by a contract. The fix is to remove it or mark it nofollow or sponsored. Disavow only when a manual action is likely.
Want help applying this to your business? Talk it through on a free 30-minute call.
Book a callWhen is a sitewide link risky?
When its main job is to move rankings rather than help a visitor. Google's spam policy defines link spam as links made "primarily for the purpose of manipulating search rankings" and lists this among its examples:
"Widely distributed links in the footers or templates of various sites" (Google Search Central: Spam policies)
Where the link sits doesn't decide it. Run each footer, sidebar or menu link through four questions. One "yes" is a warning; two or more is a link to fix.
| Question | Safe answer | Risky answer |
|---|---|---|
| Was money, a discount or a service traded for it? | No, they chose to link | Yes, and it passes ranking credit |
| What does the link say? | Your business name | A keyword, like "roof repair Austin" |
| How many sites carry it? | One partner, one relationship | Dozens of unrelated sites at once |
| Was it a condition of a deal? | No | A contract or terms of service required it |
The last row surprises people. Google's list includes "Requiring a link as part of a Terms of Service, contract, or similar arrangement without allowing a third-party content owner the choice of qualifying the outbound link" (Google: Spam policies). "Qualifying" means adding a tag like nofollow that tells Google not to pass ranking credit.
For what sitewide links are and how much weight Google gives them, see sitewide backlinks: what they are and how Google treats them. This page is about spotting the bad ones and fixing them.
Which sitewide links should I check?
Three kinds, and you control them differently:
- Links to your site from other sites. You can't edit them. You can ask the owner to change them, or disavow.
- Links from your site to other sites. Partner, supplier or sister-company links in your own footer. You can fix these today.
- Links you require others to place. A "Website by" or "Powered by" credit that your contract or software terms make mandatory.
Your own menu and footer links to your own pages are fine. Leave them alone.
How do I find sitewide links pointing to my site?
Use the free Links report in Google Search Console. Go to Links, then External links, then Top linking sites. It lists "the root domain of sites with the most links to your site, sorted by count of links" (Search Console Help: Links report).
A sitewide link shows up as one site with a link count far above the rest. A small café blog with 900 links to you, when most sites send 1 to 5, almost certainly has you in its footer or sidebar. Click the site to see which of your pages it links to, then open one of its pages and look.
Know the report's limits, from the same help page:
- It is a sample, not every link.
- Tables stop at 1,000 rows.
- It "doesn't specify if a link is marked as nofollow," so check the page source or ask the owner.
How do I fix a risky sitewide link?
Remove it, or make it pass no ranking credit. Google allows paid links when they carry `rel="sponsored"` or `rel="nofollow"` (Google: Spam policies), and prefers sponsored for "advertisements or paid placements" (Google Search Central: Qualify your outbound links).
| What you found | Fix |
|---|---|
| A footer link you paid for on other sites | Ask the site to add sponsored, or remove it. Stop renewing it. |
| A keyword anchor on a real partner's site | Ask them to change it to your business name |
| Links from a free widget or theme you gave out | Add nofollow to the widget link or remove it, as Google's 2016 widget reminder tells makers (Google Search Central Blog) |
| A credit your contract requires | Change the terms so the client may nofollow it, or drop the requirement |
| Links you can't get changed, plus a manual action risk | Disavow them (next section) |
Keep a simple log: site, date you asked, reply. If you ever need a reconsideration request, Google asks for documentation of what you removed and why some links stayed (Search Console Help: Manual Actions report).
Should I disavow sitewide backlinks?
Usually no. Google's disavow page says:
"In most cases, Google can assess which links to trust without additional guidance, so most sites will not need to use this tool." (Search Console Help: Disavow links)
It says to disavow only when you have "a considerable number of spammy, artificial, or low-quality links" and they have caused, or likely will cause, a manual action. It also warns the tool "can potentially harm your site's performance" if used wrongly. For a sitewide link, use the `domain:` line in the file, since one site gives you hundreds of URLs. Try removal first: Google says blindly disavowing everything "is not considered a good-faith effort" (Search Console Help: Manual Actions report). The full steps are in Google manual action: how to find it, fix it and ask for review.
Can footer links on my own site get me penalized?
Yes, if they look traded. Google's policy names "Excessive link exchanges" and "partner pages exclusively for the sake of cross-linking" (Google: Spam policies). A footer reading "Our partners" with keyword links to five businesses that all link back is that pattern.
Google has a separate manual action for this, "Unnatural links from your site." Its fix: remove the links or change them so they "no longer pass PageRank," for example with nofollow (Search Console Help: Manual Actions report).
Safe footer habits:
- Link partners by their business name, only where a customer would want the link.
- Mark sponsor and paid links sponsored.
- If you run several sites (say, one per brand), link them where it helps a customer, not from every page with keyword anchors.
Example
A roofer with a paid footer package
A roofer pays $200 a month for a footer link on 15 home blogs, anchor "roof repair Austin." The Links report shows each blog with hundreds of links. That fails three of the four questions. Fix: cancel, ask each blog to remove or sponsor-tag the link, and log the replies. $2,400 a year was buying risk.
A web designer's required credit
A designer's contract says clients must keep "Austin Web Design" in the footer as a followed link, across 60 client sites. That matches Google's terms-of-service example. Fix: rewrite the contract so clients may add nofollow, and add it on the sites the designer still manages.
A bakery's partner footer
A bakery lists the coffee roaster it buys from, by name, in its footer. The roaster links back. One real supplier, plain anchor, no payment: no fix needed.
FAQ
Is every link in a footer risky?
No. Most are normal navigation or honest credits. Risk comes from payment, keyword anchors, scale across unrelated sites, or a contract requiring the link.
How do I know if Google has already penalized me?
Check Search Console's Manual Actions report. If it lists "Unnatural links" to or from your site, follow its steps. If empty, there's no manual penalty.
Do I need a paid tool to find sitewide links?
No. Search Console's Top linking sites view shows the sites sending you the most links, where sitewide links stand out. Paid tools are optional.
Will adding nofollow to a partner link hurt the partner?
It stops the link passing ranking credit, but visitors can still click it. For a paid or traded link, that's what Google asks for.
Different for you?
- You want a full review of every link, not just sitewide ones: see backlink audit: review your links without overreacting.
- You aren't sure which tag to use: read nofollow vs dofollow links: when to use each.
- Your anchors are mostly keywords: check backlink anchor text: the mix of branded and exact match.
- You'd rather have someone run the checks and fixes: the SEO agent does this work.