SEO challenges: 9 common problems and how to solve them
Short answer Most SEO challenges a small business faces come from outside: Google changes its ranking several times a year, AI answers take clicks, and directories and nearby rivals compete for the same searches. You can't stop any of that. You can control whether Google can read your pages, whether they answer real questions, and whether your Business Profile is complete.
Want help applying this to your business? Talk it through on a free 30-minute call.
Book a callThe 9 SEO challenges, and the first fix for each
These are the problems that come from outside your business: Google, AI tools, competitors and big websites. Problems inside it (time, budget, an agency that doesn't deliver) are a different list.
| # | Challenge | How you notice it | First fix |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Google updates reshuffle rankings | Traffic jumps or drops in the same week as an announced update | Wait for the update to finish, then compare |
| 2 | AI Overviews answer before the click | Impressions hold, clicks fall | Go after searches that end in a call or booking |
| 3 | ChatGPT and other assistants pick who to name | You never come up when you ask them | Let their crawlers in; get listed where they look |
| 4 | Generic content doesn't rank | Pages indexed, but stuck on page 3 or lower | Add what only you know: prices, local jobs, photos |
| 5 | Google can't find or index pages | Service pages missing from Search Console | Fix blocks, then request indexing |
| 6 | The site is slow or awkward on a phone | Visitors leave fast; poor Core Web Vitals | Fix the slowest page you sell from |
| 7 | Few sites link to you | Rivals with weaker pages outrank you | Earn local links; never buy them |
| 8 | Maps is crowded, and some rivals cheat | You rank near your office, vanish a few miles out | Complete the profile; report fake listings |
| 9 | Directories and big sites take the top spots | Yelp, Angi or lists fill page one | Be listed and reviewed on those sites too |
Start with 5 and 6. A page Google can't read or a phone can't load cancels every fix below it.
1. Google algorithm updates
Google changes how it ranks pages all the time, and announces the big ones. It says it makes broad changes "several times a year," plus smaller ones it doesn't announce (Google Search Central: core updates). In 2026 so far it has run core updates in March, May and November (still rolling out on November 16), and spam updates in March, June, August and September (Google Search Status Dashboard).
A core update isn't aimed at you:
"These changes are broad in nature, and don't target specific sites or individual web pages." (Google Search Central: core updates)
Fix: don't touch anything while an update is rolling out. Afterwards, compare the weeks before and after in Search Console. For a small slip, Google says: "There's no need to take drastic action." A big drop needs a page-by-page review: traffic dropped after a Google core update.
2. AI Overviews take clicks
When Google writes an AI answer at the top, fewer people click a link. Pew Research tracked 900 US adults' Google searches in March 2025:
"Users who encountered an AI summary clicked on a traditional search result link in 8% of all visits. Those who did not encounter an AI summary clicked on a search result nearly twice as often (15% of visits)." (Pew Research Center, 2025)
There is no special trick to get into them:
"There are no additional requirements to appear in AI Overviews or AI Mode, nor other special optimizations necessary." (Google Search Central: AI features and your website)
Fix: Google says a page must be indexed and allowed to show a snippet to be a source link (Google Search Central: AI features and your website). Then judge SEO by calls and bookings, not visits. "What is a root canal" loses clicks; "emergency dentist open Saturday" still gets them. More: AI Overviews for local businesses.
3. AI assistants decide who to recommend
People now ask ChatGPT, Gemini or Copilot for "a good plumber near me." These tools search the web and name a few businesses. If their crawler is blocked, you can't be one of them:
"Sites that are opted out of OAI-SearchBot will not be shown in ChatGPT search answers, though can still appear as navigational links." (OpenAI: Overview of OpenAI crawlers)
Fix: check that your robots.txt (the file that tells crawlers what they may read) doesn't block search crawlers: should you block AI crawlers?. Then be present on the sources they read: where ChatGPT finds local businesses.
4. Content that sounds like everyone else's
A page that says what a hundred other sites say has no reason to outrank them. Google describes what it rewards:
"Google's automated ranking systems are designed to prioritize helpful, reliable information that's created to benefit people, and not content that's created to manipulate search engine rankings." (Google Search Central: Creating helpful content)
Its checklist asks whether a page shows "first-hand expertise and a depth of knowledge." Mass-producing pages, by AI or by hand, can break the spam rule on scaled content abuse: "many pages are generated for the primary purpose of manipulating search rankings and not helping users" (Google: Spam policies).
Fix: fewer, better pages. Add what a stranger can't copy: your price ranges, the towns you work in, photos of real jobs, the questions customers ask you. Whether AI drafts are allowed: does Google penalize AI content?.
5. Pages Google can't find or index
If Google hasn't indexed (stored) a page, it can't rank. Common causes on small sites: a leftover "hide from search engines" setting after a redesign, a page with no links pointing to it, or a robots.txt rule blocking it.
Fix: open Search Console's Page indexing report and check every page you sell from. Steps in order: website not showing up on Google and crawled or discovered, not indexed.
6. A slow or clumsy phone site
Google ranks the phone version of your site, not the desktop one: it uses the mobile version "for indexing and ranking" (Google Search Central: mobile-first indexing). Its speed targets, the Core Web Vitals, are main content shown within 2.5 seconds, taps answered in under 200 milliseconds and a layout that barely shifts (Google: Core Web Vitals).
Speed is not the top factor, though:
"Google Search always seeks to show the most relevant content, even if the page experience is sub-par." (Google Search Central: page experience)
Fix: fix real slowness on the pages that bring calls; don't chase a perfect score. See Core Web Vitals and ranking.
7. Too few links, and the shortcut that backfires
Links from other sites still help Google judge you, and new local sites have almost none. The shortcut, buying links, is spam: "Link spam is the practice of creating links to or from a site primarily for the purpose of manipulating search rankings" (Google: Spam policies). It can lead to a manual action, a penalty applied by a Google reviewer.
Fix: earn local links: suppliers, trade associations, chamber of commerce, sponsorships, local news. How: backlinks for a local business.
8. A crowded map, and rivals who cheat
On Google Maps you compete block by block. Google says local results are "mainly based on relevance, distance, and popularity," so a shop closer to the searcher can beat a better one farther away. You can't pay your way up:
"There's no way to request or pay for a better local ranking on Google." (Google Business Profile Help)
Some competitors stuff keywords into their business name or create fake listings.
Fix: pick the right primary category, fill in every field, keep reviews coming, and report fakes. See rank higher on Google Maps and report fake Google Business listings.
9. Directories and big sites own page one
For many service searches, Yelp, Angi, Houzz or "best of" lists hold the top results. A small site may never beat them for the broad term.
Fix: search your top three services in your city and note which sites show up. Be listed and reviewed on those, so you win the click either way. Then aim your own pages at narrower searches: one service plus one town. See local citations and directories and keyword research for a local business.
Example
A roofer after a core update
A roofer's leads from Google fall by a third in the week of a core update. He waits until Google marks the update finished, then compares. Only his blog posts dropped; his service pages and calls held. He leaves the site alone.
A dental office invisible in ChatGPT
A Calgary dentist asks ChatGPT for dentists near her office and isn't named. Her web host's security setting blocks every bot. Allowing search crawlers and filling in her Bing Places listing are the first two fixes.
A cleaning company buried under directories
A cleaning company can't reach page one for "house cleaning Austin." Thumbtack and Yelp hold it. The owner builds out both profiles, asks recent clients for reviews there, and writes a page for "move-out cleaning in Round Rock," a narrower search with fewer rivals.
FAQ
What is the biggest SEO challenge for a small business?
Usually being found at all: pages that aren't indexed, or a Business Profile that's thin. Fix those before anything about updates or AI.
How often does Google update its algorithm?
Google says it makes broad core updates several times a year and smaller changes more often. It lists confirmed ones on the Google Search Status Dashboard.
Can I stop AI Overviews from taking my clicks?
Not without hiding your page from Google. Focus on searches where people want to hire someone, which still send calls.
Should I change my site during a Google update?
No. Wait until the update is marked complete, then compare traffic before and after.
Different for you?
- Traffic fell suddenly: traffic dropped after a Google core update or after a redesign.
- You can't tell if SEO is working at all: is my SEO working?
- The problem is only Google Maps: local SEO checklist.
- You'd rather have it handled: see the SEO agent.