Truth about SEO: what really works and what doesn't
Short answer SEO works when a page truly answers what buyers search, Google can find it, and real customers vouch for the business. Bought links, keyword stuffing, word-count targets, fake freshness and mass AI pages don't work: Google's own guidance calls them useless or spam. Results take weeks to months, so judge SEO by calls and bookings, not traffic.
Want help applying this to your business? Talk it through on a free 30-minute call.
Book a callWhat really works in SEO, and what doesn't?
Google publishes what it ignores and what it punishes. Read together, its guidance sorts the common advice into two piles.
Drop these:
| Tactic | Verdict | What Google says |
|---|---|---|
| Buying links, or trading goods for them | Spam | "Buying or selling links for ranking purposes" is listed as link spam (Spam policies) |
| Repeating keywords to hit a percentage | Spam | Keyword stuffing "is against Google's spam policies" (SEO Starter Guide). See keyword density |
| The meta keywords tag | Ignored | "Google Search doesn't use the keywords meta tag." (SEO Starter Guide) |
| Writing to a word count | Ignored | There is "no magical word count target, minimum or maximum" (SEO Starter Guide) |
| A keyword in the domain name | Almost no effect | Domain keywords alone "have hardly any effect beyond appearing in breadcrumbs" (SEO Starter Guide). See exact match domains |
| New dates or bulk posts to look "fresh" | Doesn't work | Asked whether this helps rankings, Google answers "(No, it won't)" (Creating helpful content) |
| Hundreds of AI pages with nothing new | Spam | Mass-produced pages "without adding value for users" are scaled content abuse (Spam policies). See AI content |
| Fretting over the same page at two addresses | Not a penalty | Google says it's inefficient, "but it's not something that will cause a manual action" (SEO Starter Guide). Copying others' pages is different |
| Paying for a ranking guarantee | Red flag | "No one can guarantee a #1 ranking on Google." (Do you need an SEO?) |
Keep these:
| Practice | Why | Go deeper |
|---|---|---|
| A page per service that answers price, area, timing and proof | Google's systems favor content "created to benefit people" (Creating helpful content) | On-page SEO for service pages |
| A complete Google Business Profile and steady reviews | Local results rest on "relevance, distance, and popularity" (Business Profile Help) | Rank higher on Google Maps |
| A site that works on a phone | Google indexes and ranks "the mobile version of a site's content" (Mobile-first indexing) | Core Web Vitals |
| Links you earn: suppliers, associations, local press, sponsorships | Links still count; bought ones are spam | Backlinks for a local business |
| Search Console and call tracking | You can't fix what you don't measure | Is my SEO working? |
Why does SEO seem not to work?
Usually one of four reasons, in this order:
- Google can't find the page. Check that it's indexed before judging anything else. See website not showing on Google.
- The tactics are on the drop list. Bought links and stuffed pages bring nothing, or a penalty. Google says violating sites "may rank lower in results or not appear in results at all" (Spam policies).
- It's too early. Google says some changes show in hours and others take "several months", and suggests waiting a few weeks before judging (SEO Starter Guide). See how long SEO takes.
- The wrong number is tracked. Visits and rankings can rise while calls stay flat. Count calls, forms and bookings from search.
Is buying backlinks really that risky?
Yes. Google's link spam list covers paying money for links, swapping products for a link, mass link exchanges, cheap directory links and links placed by automated services. Google says it finds these through automated systems and, when needed, human review that can lead to a manual action (Spam policies). A local business gets real links from people who already know it: the supplier's dealer page, the trade association, the youth team it sponsors.
Do I need to post new content all the time?
No. Google says adding or removing lots of pages just to look fresh won't help, and it flags this habit:
"Are you changing the date of pages to make them seem fresh when the content has not substantially changed?" (Google Search Central: Creating helpful content)
Update a page when something real changed: prices, services, areas, rules. Ten strong service pages beat a weekly post nobody needs. See content decay.
Does site speed matter more than content?
No. Speed helps, but relevance comes first:
"Google Search always seeks to show the most relevant content, even if the page experience is sub-par." (Google Search Central: Understanding page experience)
The same page says Core Web Vitals, Google's speed and stability scores, are used by its ranking systems, and that there is no single page experience signal. Fix a slow phone site, then spend your time on what the page says.
Example
Illustrative cases with invented numbers.
A roofer who bought links (US dollars)
He paid $300 for 50 "high authority" links. Calls didn't change. Better use of the money: list on the manufacturer's contractor finder he qualifies for and sponsor a local event that links back.
A cleaning company blogging weekly (Canadian dollars)
It paid C$400 a month for four generic posts. Traffic rose a little; bookings didn't. It stopped, rewrote its five service pages with prices and areas, and asked every client for a review.
A dentist chasing speed scores
The site scored 95 on speed but its implant page had no price range, no photos and no dentist's name. Adding those mattered more than going from 95 to 100.
FAQ
Does SEO still work in the age of AI search?
Yes. Google says "The best practices for SEO remain relevant for AI features in Google Search" and that no special optimization is needed (AI features and your website). See is SEO dead because of AI?
Is E-E-A-T a ranking factor?
Google answers directly: "No, it's not." (SEO Starter Guide) Showing real experience and credentials still helps buyers trust you. See E-E-A-T for a small business.
Can I pay Google to rank higher on Maps?
No. Google says: "There's no way to request or pay for a better local ranking on Google." (Business Profile Help) Ads are a separate, labeled product.
Does social media count for SEO?
Not directly: Google's guide to its ranking systems names none for likes, shares or followers. Social can still bring people who later search your name. See does social media help SEO?
Different for you?
- Someone promises page one: hiring an SEO company.
- Search Console shows a penalty: Google manual action.
- Traffic fell after a Google update: core update drop.
- You want the full local list: local SEO checklist.
- You'd rather have the work done and checked: SEO & GEO Agent.