Unpopular SEO opinions: hard truths most guides skip
Short answer Anyone can sell SEO, and Google itself says no one can guarantee a top ranking. A drop after a Google update is usually a reshuffle, not a penalty. Generic blog posts rarely bring local customers. Spammy listings and bought links can work for a while, then cost you. Judge SEO by calls and bookings, not promises.
Want help applying this to your business? Talk it through on a free 30-minute call.
Book a callThe hard truths, in one table
Most SEO advice is written by people selling SEO, so a few facts get left out. Each one below rests on what Google or a regulator has published.
| Unpopular opinion | What the source says | What it means for you |
|---|---|---|
| Anyone can sell SEO | Google: "you are responsible for the actions of any companies you hire" | Vet the seller yourself |
| No one can promise page one | Google: "No one can guarantee a #1 ranking on Google." | Walk away from guarantees |
| A drop after an update is rarely a penalty | Google: core updates "don't target specific sites or individual web pages" | Check before you panic or pay for a fix |
| Most blog posts are wasted effort | Google flags lots of content on many topics "in hopes that some of it might perform well" | Write fewer, better pages about your work |
| E-E-A-T isn't a score to chase | Google: "E-E-A-T itself isn't a specific ranking factor" | Show real proof, not badges |
| Local spam often wins for a while | Keyword-stuffed names break Google's rules, yet often stay up until someone reports them | Report it; don't copy it |
| Bought links are spam | Google lists "buying or selling links for ranking purposes" as link spam | Earn links from real local ties |
Is the SEO industry regulated?
Don't count on it. Google's own hiring page puts the checking on you, the owner:
"Ultimately, you are responsible for the actions of any companies you hire, so it's best to be sure you know exactly how they intend to "help" you." (Google Search Central: Do you need an SEO?)
The same page warns about SEO firms "that email you out of the blue" and says that if one guarantees first place, "find someone else." When sellers cross into fraud, regulators step in after the damage. In a 2018 US case, the FTC charged a Florida operation with "falsely claiming to represent Google" and "falsely promising first-place or first-page placement in Google search results," for fees of $300 to $700, then $949.99 plus monthly payments (FTC, May 23, 2018).
So treat an SEO pitch like any contractor bid: ask what they'll do each month, what you'll own, and how they'll show results. The questions to ask: hiring an SEO company.
Does Google owe my business a ranking?
No. Having a website gets you eligible, not placed. Google's starter guide is blunt:
"There are no secrets here that'll automatically rank your site first in Google (sorry!)." (Google Search Central: SEO Starter Guide)
Its core updates page adds that "positions in Google Search results aren't static or fixed in place." Your spot can be taken any day by a competitor with better pages, more reviews or a closer location.
Did a Google update punish my site?
Usually not. A core update is a broad re-ranking, and Google says it doesn't single out sites. Its own analogy is a list of favorite restaurants that gets rewritten as new places open:
"The list will change, and restaurants that move down aren't necessarily "bad"; there are just other restaurants that make your top 20." (Google Search Central: Google Search's core updates and your website)
What Google tells you to do depends on the size of the drop:
| Drop | Google's advice |
|---|---|
| Small (example: position 2 to 4) | "There's no need to take drastic action" |
| Large (example: position 4 to 29) | Review the whole site for helpful, people-first content |
Recovery is slow: Google says "it could take several months" for its systems to confirm a site has improved. A real penalty is different: it's a manual action, and Search Console tells you about it (manual actions). The step-by-step check: traffic dropped after a core update.
Do blogs still work for SEO?
Some do; most small business blogs don't. The posts that fail are generic articles written because someone said "post weekly." Google lists this as a warning sign of search-engine-first content:
"Are you producing lots of content on many different topics in hopes that some of it might perform well in search results?" (Google Search Central: Creating helpful, reliable, people-first content)
The same page asks whether you write to a set word count because Google prefers one, and answers: "No, we don't." For a plumber, dentist or accountant, the pages that bring calls are usually service pages and answers to real customer questions with your prices, photos and area. What to publish instead: do blogs help SEO?
Is E-E-A-T a ranking factor?
Not directly. E-E-A-T stands for experience, expertise, authoritativeness and trustworthiness, the qualities Google's raters look for. Google says:
"While E-E-A-T itself isn't a specific ranking factor, using a mix of factors that can identify content with good E-E-A-T is useful." (Google Search Central: Creating helpful, reliable, people-first content)
So an "E-E-A-T audit" that adds author boxes and trust badges misses the point. Real licenses, named staff, job photos and reviews are the proof (E-E-A-T for a small business).
Why do spammy local listings outrank me?
Because spam can work until someone reports it. A competitor named "Best Plumber Austin 24/7 Cheap" is breaking Google's rules:
"Including unnecessary information in your business name isn't permitted, and could result in the suspension of your Business Profile." (Google Business Profile Help: Guidelines for representing your business on Google)
The fix is a report to Google with evidence (report fake listings). Don't copy the trick: the same rule can suspend your profile.
The same goes for clever map tactics sold as local hacks. Google says local results are "mainly based on relevance, distance, and popularity," and:
"There's no way to request or pay for a better local ranking on Google." (Google Business Profile Help: Tips to improve your local ranking on Google)
What actually moves a profile: rank higher on Google Maps.
Do spammy backlinks still work?
Sometimes, briefly, and that's why they're still sold. Google's spam policy lists "buying or selling links for ranking purposes" as link spam, including "exchanging money for links" and "excessive link exchanges." Paying for 500 links is paying for risk. Links from suppliers, associations and local press are safer (backlinks for a local business).
Example
Illustrative cases with round numbers, not client results.
A landscaper offered "page one in 30 days"
The seller wants US $1,500 up front and won't say what work is included. Google's hiring page says to walk away from guarantees. She asks for a monthly task list and a sample report instead; the seller stops replying.
An Ottawa dental clinic drops after a core update
Its "teeth whitening" page slides from position 3 to 5. That's a small drop, so the clinic changes nothing for a month and keeps watching bookings, which hold at about 40 a month. It skips a CAD $3,000 "penalty recovery" offer.
A roofer posting four blogs a month
After a year, 48 posts bring almost no calls. He stops the blog and spends the same US $800 a month on six service pages with job photos, prices and the towns he covers.
FAQ
Can an SEO company guarantee first place?
No. Google says "No one can guarantee a #1 ranking on Google," and the FTC has sued sellers who promised it.
Is it worth blogging at all?
Yes, if each post answers a question your customers actually ask and shows your own work. A weekly generic post is the pattern Google warns about.
Should I copy a competitor who stuffs keywords into their business name?
No. It breaks Google's name rule and can get your profile suspended. Report theirs instead.
How long does recovery from a core update take?
Google says some changes show in days, but it "could take several months" to confirm a site improved. Sometimes it takes the next core update.
Different for you?
- You're about to hire someone: hiring an SEO company
- Your traffic fell after an update: traffic dropped after a core update
- You got a manual action notice: Google manual action
- A fake listing outranks you: report fake Google Business listings
- You want to know if your SEO is paying off: is my SEO working?
- You'd rather have it done and measured for you: SEO & GEO Agent