SEO agency for startups: how to choose on a startup budget
Short answer Most startups shouldn't sign a big monthly SEO retainer on day one. Buy a one-time setup while the site is built, do the free basics yourself, and add a monthly agency only once you know which customers and searches pay. In Ahrefs' survey of 439 providers, agencies averaged $3,209 a month and freelancers $1,348.
Want help applying this to your business? Talk it through on a free 30-minute call.
Book a callShould a startup hire an SEO agency?
Hire for the build, not for a year. Google's own advice on hiring an SEO names a new site as the moment:
"For example, a great time to hire is when you're considering a site redesign (the earlier, the better), or planning to launch a new site" (Google Search Central: Do you need an SEO?)
Fixing structure later costs more than getting it right before launch. A big monthly retainer, though, can wait until you know what sells. Match the spend to your stage:
| Stage | What you need | Who should do it |
|---|---|---|
| Site being built | Clean page structure, one page per service, titles, Search Console set up, Business Profile if you meet customers in person | One-time project with an SEO, or a web builder who knows SEO |
| First 3–6 months | Reviews, listings, a few pages for searches you can win, watching Search Console | Mostly you, plus a few hours of expert review |
| Customers and margins proven | Steady new pages, links, regular reports tied to leads | Monthly freelancer or agency |
Why wait on the retainer? Results are slow at first. Google says "Some changes might take effect in a few hours, others could take several months" (Google Search Central: SEO Starter Guide). A brand-new site has little history, so early months mostly build the base. See how long SEO takes for the timeline.
What a startup needs from SEO in year one
Two kinds of startups need different things. Know which one you are before you talk to an agency.
- You serve a local area (a plumber, clinic, salon, bookkeeper). Your first wins come from Google Maps: a complete Business Profile, reviews, and service pages. The local SEO checklist covers this, and most of it is free.
- You sell online or nationwide (software, ecommerce, a service delivered remotely). Established brands own the broad searches. Your first wins are narrow, specific searches: a problem, a use case, a comparison. Keyword research shows which ones people type.
Either way, the year-one job is small: get found for the few searches that match what you sell, and track whether those visits turn into calls, bookings or sign-ups.
How much does an SEO agency cost a startup?
Ahrefs surveyed 439 SEO providers (updated 2024). The figures, in US dollars:
| Measure | Monthly |
|---|---|
| Most common retainer (20.4% of providers) | $501–$1,000 |
| Freelancer average | $1,348 |
| Agency average | $3,209 |
| All providers average | $2,917 |
Source: Ahrefs: SEO Pricing.
A low price is not a bargain if the work doesn't fit your stage. For a new business, a fixed project fee for setup plus a small monthly check-in often costs less than a full retainer and does what's needed. For US vs Canada prices and what each level buys, see SEO cost for a small business.
How to choose an SEO agency as a startup
Ask the usual questions first (hiring an SEO company lists them). Then ask the ones that matter for a new business:
| Ask | A good answer | Walk away if |
|---|---|---|
| What would you do in the first 90 days on a brand-new site? | A short list tied to your services and customers | The same package they sell everyone |
| Can you show results for a site that started from zero? | A past client's Search Console or lead numbers, before and after | Only rankings for big brands' sites |
| Which searches can a site with no history win? | Specific, narrow searches, with reasons | Your biggest industry keyword on page one |
| Can we start with a fixed project or month to month? | Yes, with scope in writing | Only 12-month contracts |
| How will we know it's working by month three? | Search Console clicks and leads, compared with launch | Rankings only, or "SEO takes a year, be patient" with no checkpoints |
| Who owns the site, domain, Search Console and analytics? | You, as owner; they get user access | They keep the accounts |
| What won't you do? | No bought links, no bought old domains, no mass pages | They describe link packages |
Google also says "No one can guarantee a #1 ranking on Google" (Google Search Central: Do you need an SEO?). An agency that promises one is telling you something about itself.
Deal terms that protect a startup
Startups change fast: new name, new service, new city. The contract should let you change too.
- Short term. A setup project with a set price, then monthly with 30 days' notice.
- Scope in writing. How many pages, which fixes, what report, how often.
- You own everything. Domain, hosting, Search Console, analytics and Business Profile are in your name from day one. Leaving your marketing agency shows what goes wrong when they aren't.
- A clean exit. Content and reports stay with you when you leave.
Marketing agency contract terms covers each clause in detail.
Shortcuts sold to startups that backfire
A new site with no history makes founders impatient. Three shortcuts promise a head start and break Google's spam policies:
| Shortcut | What Google's spam policies say |
|---|---|
| Buying links to "build authority" | Lists "Buying or selling links for ranking purposes" as link spam |
| Buying an old domain for its history | "Expired domain abuse is where an expired domain name is purchased and repurposed primarily to manipulate search rankings by hosting content that provides little to no value to users" |
| Hundreds of thin pages, one per keyword or city | "Scaled content abuse is when many pages are generated for the primary purpose of manipulating search rankings and not helping users" |
Source: Google Search Central: Spam policies for Google web search. A penalty on a young site can erase the little visibility it has. Buying a domain because the name fits your brand is fine; the policy targets reusing one to game rankings.
Example
A new HVAC company, one van
The owner pays a web builder about $2,500 for a site with one page per service, and spends about $600 more for an SEO to set up titles, Search Console and the Business Profile before launch. For six months he asks every customer for a review and checks Search Console monthly. With 40 jobs a month coming in, he adds a $1,000 monthly freelancer for new service and area pages.
A software startup, two founders
An agency quotes $4,000 a month on a 12-month contract, promising page one for the product's main category. The founders instead pay $3,000 once for keyword research and five pages aimed at specific problems their buyers search. They revisit a retainer after month six, once they see which pages bring sign-ups.
FAQ
When should a startup start SEO?
While the website is being planned. Google names planning a redesign or a new site launch as a great time to hire an SEO. Retainer-level work can wait until you know what sells.
Is SEO worth it for a startup with no budget?
The basics cost nothing but time: a Business Profile, Search Console, clear service pages and reviews. Paid SEO pays off once you know which searches bring customers.
Should a startup hire an SEO agency or a freelancer?
For one site and a clear task list, a freelancer often fits and costs less (an average $1,348 vs $3,209 a month in Ahrefs' survey). See agency vs freelancer vs in-house.
Can an agency get a new website ranking fast?
Not on broad, competitive searches. Google says some changes take several months to show. Narrow, specific searches are where a new site can show up first.
Different for you?
- You meet customers in person in one area: start with the local SEO checklist and ranking higher on Google Maps.
- You're also weighing ads for faster leads: see SEO vs Google Ads.
- You don't know how much to spend on marketing overall: see the small business marketing budget.
- You want the SEO work done for you: see SEO.