B2B SEO agency: how to vet one with a pilot before signing
Short answer Don't sign a long contract on a pitch. Ask for proof you can check: a plan in your buyers' words, starting numbers, who makes each change and what counts as a qualified lead. Then buy a paid 30-day pilot and judge the work, not rankings. At 90 days, continue, narrow or stop by rules you wrote down first.
Want help applying this to your business? Talk it through on a free 30-minute call.
Book a callHow to vet a B2B SEO agency
Test the agency in three steps, each one small enough to walk away from:
| Step | What you buy | What you judge |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Before signing | Nothing yet: a few calls and written answers | Proof they understand your buyers and will show their work |
| 2. 30-day pilot | A fixed, paid scope with named deliverables | The quality of the work, the speed of fixes, honest reporting |
| 3. 90-day checkpoint | One quarter of ongoing work | Whether pages went live and real buyers showed up, by rules set on day one |
Why not judge on rankings? Google says changes can take "several months" to show (Google Search Central: SEO Starter Guide), and "No one can guarantee a #1 ranking on Google" (Google Search Central: Do you need an SEO?). A pilot can't prove results. It can prove whether the team does careful work you can see.
B2B (selling to other businesses) makes this harder than local SEO. A plumber counts calls. A firm selling software, engineering or IT services may get five good inquiries a month, each one judged by several people over weeks. Traffic numbers say little at that volume; you need to know which visits became real sales conversations.
Scams and Google's warning signs: hiring an SEO company. Contract clauses: marketing agency contract terms.
What evidence should a B2B SEO agency show before you sign?
Written answers you can check later, not slides. Ask for each of these:
| Ask for | A good answer | A weak answer |
|---|---|---|
| A one-page plan for your business | Your top services, the job titles who buy them, and the questions they ask before they call sales | A keyword list with search volumes and nothing about who buys |
| One sample page brief | Turns one real sales question into a page: who reads it, what it answers, what they do next | "We'll write four blogs a month" |
| Your starting numbers | Current clicks, top pages and form leads from your own Search Console and Analytics, plus what isn't tracked yet | A growth promise with no starting point |
| Who makes each change | Names: they edit pages, your developer handles templates, your engineer checks technical claims | "Your team implements" for everything, which means you're buying advice |
| What a qualified lead is | Written with your sales lead: company type, size, need, region | "Leads" that include every form fill, job seeker and vendor |
| How they use AI | Where it drafts, and who with real expertise reviews before anything goes live | "Our AI publishes 100 pages a month" |
The last row matters more every year. Google lists as spam "Using generative AI tools or other similar tools to generate many pages without adding value for users" (Google Search Central: Spam policies). For technical B2B topics, Google's own self-check asks:
"Is this content written or reviewed by an expert or enthusiast who demonstrably knows the topic well?" (Google Search Central: Creating helpful, reliable, people-first content)
If your engineers or partners must review every page, the plan should say how many hours a month that takes from them.
While you're only talking, share data but not control. Google's advice: "only grant read access to Search Console (at this stage, don't grant them write access)" (Google Search Central: Do you need an SEO?).
How do you run a 30-day SEO pilot?
Write the scope down, pay for it, and keep every output if you leave. A pilot should be big enough to show judgment and small enough to finish.
Agree before day 1:
- 3–5 priority pages or services in scope, and what's out of scope.
- The starting numbers above, saved as a dated export.
- One owner on each side, and who approves changes to pricing claims, product claims and redirects.
- The lead definition, signed off by whoever runs sales.
- Which accounts the agency gets, at which level, and how access ends.
What to get back by day 30:
- A ranked list of technical fixes, each with the reason and who fixes it.
- One finished page, reviewed by your expert, live on the site.
- A check that form, call and demo-request tracking actually fires.
- A change log: date, page, what changed, why, who approved.
For the log, Search Console now lets you add dated notes to its performance chart. Google suggests marking "SEO efforts like implementing a new plugin or hiring an agency" (Google Search Central Blog: custom annotations). Notes are up to 120 characters and visible to "everyone with access to your Search Console property" (same post), so later you can line up each change with what happened next.
What not to judge at day 30: rankings and traffic. A jump that early is usually noise, and a dip isn't failure either.
What should you check at day 30?
Score the process, since results come later:
| Check | Pass | Pause |
|---|---|---|
| Did the work ship? | The page and the agreed fixes are live | Still "in review" or waiting on access nobody chased |
| Was the page right? | Your expert made small edits | Your expert rewrote it, or found factual errors |
| Did they use your input? | Your sales questions show up in the page and the plan | The plan reads like any other client's |
| Is tracking trustworthy? | Each lead source is tested, and the gaps are named | Numbers nobody can explain |
| Did they raise problems early? | You heard about blockers in week one or two | Surprises on day 30 |
A pause means: fix the misses before you expand the scope. Signing on for more months doesn't fix a pilot that didn't ship.
What belongs in the 90-day decision gate?
Three possible decisions, each with conditions you write before the quarter starts. Fill in your own thresholds; here's the shape:
| Decision | When |
|---|---|
| Continue | Agreed pages are live, the change log is current, tracking works, and qualified inquiries are being recorded with the reason they qualified |
| Narrow | Work is good but slow: cut the scope to what they ship well, or move page edits in-house |
| Stop | Work keeps missing, access stays blocked, or reports still stop at traffic and never reach qualified leads |
At 90 days, still don't demand a revenue number. A B2B sale may take longer than a quarter to close. Do demand a clean trail from search to sales: which page a lead landed on, whether sales accepted it, and why.
Google Analytics has standard event names for exactly that trail. Among them:
qualify_lead: "This event measures when a user is marked as meeting the criteria to become a qualified lead." (Google Analytics for developers: Recommended events)
There are matching events for a disqualified lead (with the reason), first contact by a sales rep, and a lead that became a customer (same page). An agency that wires your sales tool into these events, or keeps the same trail in a spreadsheet, gives you something to decide on. Setting up the basic events: GA4 key events. The monthly report to ask for: marketing report and lead expectations.
Red flags during the pilot
- No pilot offered, only a 12-month contract. Ask why the first month can't stand alone.
- They want admin access on day one. For a pilot, give what the work needs, and keep ownership of every account yourself.
- Deliverables measured in hours or "tasks". Ask which pages and fixes you'll see.
- Reports stop at traffic. Ask how sales feedback reaches them.
- Ranking promises. Google says to find someone else if an SEO guarantees first place (Google Search Central: Do you need an SEO?).
And whatever they do: "Ultimately, you are responsible for the actions of any companies you hire" (same page).
Example
Illustrative cases, not real businesses.
IT managed-services firm, USD 3,000 a month
The proposal promises 20 blog posts a month. Before signing, the owner asks for one sample page brief built from a real sales question ("What does a SOC 2 audit need from our IT provider?"). The agency delivers a good one, so she buys a 30-day pilot at USD 3,000 for that page plus a technical fix list. Her security lead edits it lightly; it goes live in week three. She continues.
Engineering consultancy in Alberta, CAD 4,000 a month
The pilot page comes back with two wrong code references. The agency's writer had no engineer reviewing. At day 30 the owner pauses, the agency adds a review step with one of his engineers at two hours a month, and the next page passes. At 90 days he narrows the scope to one page a month instead of four.
B2B software company, USD 6,000 a month
At 90 days traffic is up, but the report shows form fills only. Sales says most are students and vendors. The agreed gate said reports must show qualified inquiries, so the company stops and keeps the change log, pages and tracking setup.
FAQ
How long should an SEO pilot be?
Thirty days is enough to judge process: shipped work, accuracy, tracking and communication. It's not enough to judge rankings, which Google says can take several months to move.
Should I pay for an SEO pilot?
Yes. Paid work has a scope and deliverables you own. A free audit is a sales tool; if you allow one, give read-only access.
What results should a B2B SEO agency show at 90 days?
Agreed pages live, a current change log, working tracking and qualified inquiries recorded with reasons. Revenue may take longer when deals take months to close.
How many qualified leads should B2B SEO bring?
There's no standard number; it depends on your market size, deal size and starting point. Set the target from your own baseline and sales capacity, then work backward.
Different for you?
- Not sure you need an agency at all: agency vs freelancer vs in-house vs AI
- Checking whether a quote is fair: what SEO costs
- Already hired and unsure it's working: is my SEO working?
- Timeline for a new site: how long SEO takes
- Leaving an agency that holds your accounts: leaving your agency
- Want the work done for you: SEO & GEO Agent