Products SEO & GEO Agent Paid Ads Agent Website Agent Conversion Agent
How it works Pricing FAQ Blog Book a call

SEO consultation: how to prepare for the first call

Updated · 6 min read

Short answer Before the call, write down your goal in customers, your best services and area, and last year's numbers from Search Console and your call log. Send it to two or three providers. Give no logins yet. On the call, listen for questions about your business, then ask for a written proposal with scope, timeline and exit terms.

Want help applying this to your business? Talk it through on a free 30-minute call.

Book a call

How to prepare for an SEO consultation

Bring five things. Together they let a provider judge your case in one call instead of guessing.

BringWhere it comes fromWhy it matters
One goal in customersYou: "10 more roof repair jobs a month"A provider can plan for jobs, not for "more traffic"
Your top 3 services and the area you serveYouThese decide which searches are worth winning
Search Console numbers for the last 12 monthsSearch Console, Performance reportShows how many people already find you, and on which searches
Calls, forms and bookings per monthYour phone log, booking tool or CRM (the system where you track leads)The baseline any result is measured against
3 competitors who show up above youA Google search for your main service and cityShows who you're up against

Search Console is Google's free tool that shows how your site does in Google Search. Its Performance report lists clicks, impressions (how often you appeared) and the searches people typed. It opens on the last three months by default; change the date filter to see a full year (Search Console Help). If you've never set it up, say so on the call. That is useful news in itself. Which numbers matter most is in is my SEO working?

Add one line on budget, even a range. A provider who knows the range can tell you what fits inside it; one who doesn't will pitch their biggest package.

What to send when you first reach out

Keep the first message to five lines. The form on their site, an email and a phone call all work. Email or a form gives you a written record of what you asked for, which helps when you compare answers later.

A message that gets a useful reply:

  1. Who you are: "We're a two-van plumbing company in Tucson."
  2. The goal: "We want more water heater jobs from Google."
  3. Where you stand: "About 300 Search Console clicks a month, mostly on our name."
  4. Budget range and start date.
  5. The ask: "Can we book a call, and what do you need from me first?"

Contact two or three providers, not ten. You'll compare proposals side by side, and more than three becomes hard to judge. Skip anyone who contacted you first. Google tells owners to treat unsolicited SEO emails with the same doubt as "burn fat at night" diet pills (Google Search Central).

What access to give before the first call

None yet. To show your numbers, use the Share button in the Search Console Performance report. Google says the link shows only that report view and doesn't let the person take any action on your account (Search Console Help).

If they offer a free audit and need more, Google's rule is narrow:

"only grant read access to Search Console (at this stage, don't grant them write access)." (Google Search Central)

Never share your Google password. Add people as users so you can remove them later. How to keep ownership of every account is in hiring an SEO company.

What a good SEO consultant asks you

The first call should feel like an interview of your business, not a sales pitch. Google gives the test:

"Your SEO should ask questions about what makes your business unique, who your competitors are, how search results can help, and how your customers find you." (Google Search Central)

Google adds: "If they're not interested, find someone who is" (same page). If the call is mostly slides about the provider, that's your answer.

Questions to ask on the first call

Keep it to four. The full list, with good and bad answers, is in hiring an SEO company.

  • What would you do in the first 90 days, and why? You want named pages and fixes, not "a strategy".
  • What results do you expect, and by when? Google says some changes "could take several months" to show, and to wait "a few weeks" before judging (SEO Starter Guide). A firm date for page one is a warning.
  • How will I see what you changed? Google suggests asking whether they'll "share with me all the changes you make to my site" (Google Search Central).
  • Can I talk to two current clients? Google tells owners to check references and ask past clients whether the work was useful and produced positive results (same page).

Write down the answers during the call. You'll compare them with the proposal.

What the proposal should say

A proposal is where talk becomes a promise you can hold them to. Google describes what an audit should deliver:

"An SEO audit should be about giving you realistic estimates of improvement, and an estimate of the work involved." (Google Search Central)

Check that it names:

  • The work. Pages to write or fix, profile updates, technical fixes, each with a month.
  • The measure. Calls, forms and Search Console clicks against your current numbers, not a ranking.
  • The report. How often, and from which accounts. Your own Search Console beats their tool's screenshots.
  • The price. Monthly fee, setup fee, and anything billed extra. Whether it's fair: what SEO costs a small business.

If it guarantees a #1 spot, stop. "No one can guarantee a #1 ranking on Google" (Google Search Central).

Contract basics before you sign

Four terms decide how much risk you carry. Get each one in writing.

TermWhat to look for
Length and noticeA short first term or month-to-month, and a notice period you can live with
OwnershipYour website, domain, Search Console and Business Profile stay in your business's name
Your contentPages they write belong to you if you leave
Ending itWhat you get back on the way out: logins, files, the change log

Clause by clause, with the US and Canadian copyright rules on who owns the work: marketing agency contract terms. This is general information, not legal advice; a lawyer can read a long contract for you.

Example

Illustrative cases. Figures are invented for the example.

A landscaper who came prepared

She sends three providers one message: residential design jobs, 25-mile area, 450 Search Console clicks a month, about 12 inquiries a month, budget $1,000 to $1,500. Two reply with questions; one replies with a price list. She books calls with the two.

A dentist asked for her password

On the call, the provider asks for her Google login to "run the audit". She shares a Search Console report link instead and offers restricted access if they send a written audit scope. They agree, and the audit arrives a week later.

An accountant comparing proposals

One proposal promises "top 3 for 20 keywords". The other lists six service pages, profile fixes and a monthly report on calls and clicks, on a three-month first term with 30 days' notice. He signs the second.

FAQ

Do I need to know SEO before the consultation?

No. Google says a small local business "can probably do much of the work yourself" and points to its SEO Starter Guide (Google Search Central).

Should I pay for an SEO consultation?

Pay when you want a plan to carry out yourself. If you plan to hire them monthly, the first call is a sales call; treat it that way.

Will running Google Ads help my SEO?

No. Google says advertising "won't have any effect on your site's presence in our search results" (Google Search Central). Choosing between them: SEO vs Google Ads.

What if I don't have Search Console?

Say so on the call; setting it up is a normal first task. Set it up under your business's Google account and add the provider as a user.

Different for you?

Keep learning

NextDigital marketing agency for small business: how to choose oneWhat a digital marketing agency does for a small business, which services to buy first, what it costs, agency vs an in-house hire, and how to pick one.

Ask us one question

One line is enough. We reply by email.

Sources

  1. Google Search Central: Do you need an SEO?
  2. Google Search Central: SEO Starter Guide
  3. Search Console Help: Performance report, overview and basic setup