SEO provider reports: how to check the numbers are real
Short answer Don't check the report against itself. Make sure you own Search Console, Google Analytics and your Business Profile, then compare each number in the report with the same date range there. Small gaps are normal; opposite trends are not. Be wary of keyword counts, tool scores, impressions alone and calls that include ads.
Want help applying this to your business? Talk it through on a free 30-minute call.
Book a callHow to check an SEO report: compare it with your own accounts
A report is only as honest as the data behind it. The fix is simple: look at the same numbers yourself, in Google's free tools, for the same dates.
| What the report says | Where you check it | What should match |
|---|---|---|
| Clicks or visits from Google | Search Console → Performance | The direction of the trend, month by month |
| Rankings | Search Console → Performance → Average position | Roughly the same story for the same searches |
| Leads, calls, form fills | Your call log, inbox and booking calendar | Real people you can name |
| Profile calls and directions | Google Business Profile → Performance | Same figures, and whether ads are mixed in |
| Links built | Search Console → Links → Top linking sites | The sites they named show up over time |
Two rules make this work:
- Same date range. A report that compares this month with a slow month last winter looks better than one that compares with the same month last year.
- Your own login. If the provider set up these accounts under their own email, you're reading a copy, not the source.
Do you own your Search Console and Analytics?
You should be an owner, and the provider a user. In Search Console, an owner "has full control" and "can add and remove other users," while a full user "has view rights to all data and can take some actions," per Search Console Help. Check under Settings → Users and permissions. If you see "Owner" next to their email and nothing next to yours, fix that first.
Google's own advice for the first weeks with any SEO:
"If your SEO offers to do an SEO audit for you, be sure to carefully consider what's involved and only grant read access to Search Console (at this stage, don't grant them write access)." (Google Search Central: Do you need an SEO?)
The same goes for Google Analytics and your Business Profile: your email as owner or administrator, theirs as a user you can remove. If you leave, you keep the history. More on that in marketing agency contract terms.
SEO report red flags: numbers that look good but mean little
| Report shows | Why it can mislead | Ask instead |
|---|---|---|
| "450 keywords ranking" | Tool counts can include positions far down the results and searches almost nobody makes | Which 10 money searches moved, and their clicks |
| Rankings from a tool | Google says third-party tools "don't have access to Google's internal ranking data" (Do you need an SEO?). Local results also change with the searcher's location | The same searches in Search Console |
| Impressions doubled | Search Console usually counts an impression when your link is on the results page, "whether or not the item is scrolled into view" (Search Console Help) | Clicks on searches without your business name |
| Domain Authority or an "SEO score" up | A tool company's number, not Google's | Calls and bookings from search |
| "Website traffic up 40%" | May include ads, social, email and your own visits | Organic Search only, in Analytics |
| "Conversions up" | In Google Analytics, any event can be marked as a key event. With a linked Google Ads account and ads personalization on, Analytics marks events such as session_start (a visit) as key events by default (Analytics Help) | Which events count, and does each one mean a lead |
| Profile calls up | Google says profile performance "includes views, searches, and actions from both organic search results and Google Ads," and a call is a tap on the button, not an answered call (Business Profile Help) | Calls when ads were paused, or calls in your phone log |
| "Cost per click went down thanks to SEO" | In Google Ads you pay what beats "the Ad Rank of the competitor immediately below you" (Google Ads Help). Organic rank is not part of that | Treat ads and SEO as separate lines |
One number deserves a closer look: average position. Google calculates it from "the topmost position occupied by a link to your property," averaged across every search you appeared in (Search Console Help). Ranking for many new, rare searches can move the average without one extra customer. And an AI Overview counts as one position: "all links in the AI Overview are assigned that same position."
Why the report doesn't match Google Analytics or Search Console
Some gap is normal. Google says the two tools "use different metrics and systems, which means the data won't match completely," but "the general trends and patterns should be similar" (Google Search Central: Using Search Console and Google Analytics data for SEO).
So judge direction, not decimals:
- Report up 30%, Search Console up 25%: fine.
- Report up 30%, Search Console flat or down: ask which data the report used, and for which dates.
- Report shows traffic you can't find anywhere: ask for a screenshot of the source with the date range visible.
Bots aren't usually the explanation. Google Analytics automatically excludes "traffic from known bots and spiders," though you "cannot... see how much known bot traffic was excluded" (Analytics Help).
How to check the links an SEO company says it built
Open Search Console → Links → Top linking sites. If the provider says it got you listed on 20 sites, most should appear there in time (Google gives no timeline). The report shows "a sample" of links, not every one (Search Console Help), so a missing small site isn't proof of anything. A list full of sites that have nothing to do with your trade or city is.
Paid links are a risk, not a deliverable. Google lists "buying or selling links for ranking purposes" as link spam (Spam policies). See backlinks for a local business for links that are safe.
Five questions to send your SEO provider
- Which data source and date range is each number from?
- How many calls, forms and bookings came from organic search this month, and how did you count them?
- What are the 10 searches you're working on, and what are their clicks in Search Console?
- Which Google Analytics events do you count as conversions?
- Which pages and links did you add or change this month? Send the URLs.
A provider doing real work can answer all five quickly. Vague answers to questions 1 and 5 are the clearest warning. Google adds: "No one can guarantee a #1 ranking on Google" (Do you need an SEO?).
Example
Illustrative cases with invented round numbers.
A landscaper paying $1,200 a month (US dollars)
The report says "312 keywords on page 1–10." In Search Console, non-branded clicks went from 60 to 65 a month over four months. The owner asks for the 10 searches that matter; seven of them get no clicks. The provider moves effort to the lawn care and patio pages.
An accounting firm paying C$1,800 a month (Canadian dollars)
"Conversions" rose from 40 to 160. The partner opens Google Analytics: scroll depth was marked as a key event in the second month. Real form fills from organic search went from 8 to 10. Modest progress, not a 4x jump.
A physiotherapy clinic told its links grew
The report lists 25 new links. Search Console's top linking sites show 6 of them after three months; 15 are on foreign directories unrelated to health. The clinic asks for the cost and source of each link, and stops the link package.
FAQ
How often should I check my SEO provider's report?
Monthly. Ten minutes with Search Console and your call log catches most problems; is my SEO working lists the numbers to watch.
Can an SEO company fake Search Console data?
Not inside your own account. A PDF or a dashboard they host can show anything, so check the source with your own login.
Is a rising keyword count a bad sign?
No, just a weak one. It means your pages appear for more searches; it doesn't say anyone clicked or called.
My provider owns the Search Console account. What do I do?
Ask them to add you as an owner, or verify the site with your own Google account. Then review who has access under Settings → Users and permissions.
Where do I report an SEO company that misled me?
In the US, the FTC; across borders, econsumer.gov (Google names both). In Canada, the Competition Bureau takes complaints about misleading marketing.
Different for you?
- You don't have Search Console set up yet: Google Search Console for a small business.
- You're choosing a provider, not checking one: hiring an SEO company.
- You want one report covering ads, SEO and referrals: the report to ask for.
- The numbers are honest but flat: is my SEO working.
- You'd rather have SEO done with the numbers in your own accounts: SEO & GEO Agent.