Products SEO & GEO Agent Paid Ads Agent Website Agent Conversion Agent
How it works Pricing FAQ Blog Book a call

SEO scams: red flags and how to avoid predatory agencies

Updated · 8 min read

Short answer Most SEO scams take three shapes: a cold email or call that invents a problem, a guaranteed #1 ranking, or a contract that leaves the agency owning your domain, website or Google listing. Google says no one can guarantee a #1 ranking. Keep every account in your name; never pay an invoice or threat you can't trace.

Want help applying this to your business? Talk it through on a free 30-minute call.

Book a call

The SEO scam red flags, at a glance

Red flagWhat's really going onWhat to do
A stranger emails: "your site isn't on Google" or "I found 47 errors"A mass email sent to thousands of sitesCheck your own Search Console; don't reply
"Guaranteed #1 on Google" or "page one or your money back"Google says no one can promise this; the fine print picks easy wordsAsk which searches, measured how, by whom
An invoice or "renewal notice" for SEO, a listing or your domain you don't recognizeA bill for something you never orderedMatch it to a vendor you use before paying
"Pay us or we'll flood your site with bad links" or one-star reviewsExtortionDon't pay; report it
The agency registers your domain, website or Google listing in its own nameYou can't leave without losing themEvery account in your business's name
A 12- or 24-month term with a fee to leave earlyYou pay whether it works or notMonth to month, or a short first term

The first four arrive uninvited. The last two arrive in a contract you sign, which makes them harder to undo.

Is this SEO email a scam?

Almost always, if you didn't ask for it. Google's own advice:

"Be wary of SEO firms and web consultants or agencies that email you out of the blue." (Google Search Central: Do you need an SEO?)

Google adds that it gets these emails too, and shows one telling google.com it is "not listed in most of the major search engines" (same page). The pitch works because it names a fear, not a fact. Common versions:

  • "Your site isn't indexed" or "you're invisible on Google." Check it yourself in Google Search Console (free): the Page indexing report shows which of your pages Google has. See Google Search Console for a small business.
  • "We'll submit you to 1,000 search engines." Google calls submitting to thousands of search engines a typically useless exercise for ranking in the major ones (same page).
  • "I ran an audit and found serious errors." Tools flag dozens of minor items on any site. Ask which errors cost you calls, and why.
  • "Add a link to us in your footer." Google: "You should never have to link to an SEO." (same page)

Tell-tale signs: a free email address, no company website you can find, your business name filled in by a template, and urgency ("this week only").

What does a fake SEO guarantee look like?

"No one can guarantee a #1 ranking on Google." (Google Search Central: Do you need an SEO?)

Google says to beware of SEOs that claim to guarantee rankings, a "special relationship" with Google, or a "priority submit" (same page). Sellers who offer a guarantee anyway protect themselves in the fine print:

  • They pick the words. "Page one for 10 keywords" can mean rare phrases nobody types. Ask for the list before you sign, and compare it with searches that already bring you clicks in Search Console.
  • They pick the proof. Results differ by searcher and location, so a screenshot from their office proves little.
  • The refund has conditions. "Money back" often needs you to stay 12 months, approve every change, and ask in writing within a set window.
  • The fast route is risky. Quick jumps usually come from bought links, which can bring a penalty that lands on you. Google: "you are responsible for the actions of any companies you hire" (same page). If it has already happened, see Google manual action.

An honest proposal names the work (pages, fixes, profile updates), the numbers it will report (clicks, calls, form leads), and a time frame, without promising a position.

Fake invoices and domain renewal notices

The US Federal Trade Commission warned in May 2026 that small businesses get bills for things they never ordered, "maybe tech support, domain registration, or search engine optimization services." (FTC) Some say "past due" to rush you. The FTC's advice: have staff check every invoice closely, and search an unknown company's name with "scam" or "complaint" (same page).

Canada's Anti-Fraud Centre describes the same pattern: a caller "confirms" your address and phone, then sends an invoice for a directory listing or renewal, sometimes using a recording of the call against you (CAFC). It suggests giving payment authority to only a few staff (same page).

For domain notices, look up who your registrar is at lookup.icann.org (ICANN) and renew only through that company's own site.

"Pay us or we'll hurt your rankings"

Two threats, one answer: don't pay.

Bad links. Some emails threaten to point thousands of spam links at your site unless you pay. Google says:

"Google works very hard to make sure that actions on third-party sites do not negatively affect a website." (Search Console Help: Disavow links to your site)
"In most cases, Google can assess which links to trust without additional guidance, so most sites will not need to use this tool." (Search Console Help: Disavow links to your site)

That tool is the disavow file, a list telling Google to ignore certain links. Google reserves it for sites with many spammy links that have caused, or likely will cause, a manual action (same page).

One-star reviews. A wave of 1- and 2-star reviews, then a demand for money to stop. Google has a report form for this and says:

"Do not engage with or pay the malicious individuals. This can encourage further attempts and doesn't guarantee the removal of reviews." (Google Business Profile Help: Report negative review extortion scams)

Screenshot every message with its date and sender, then file the merchant extortion report form from that help page. For ordinary fake reviews, see responding to negative Google reviews.

Contracts that hold you hostage

The most expensive SEO scam is legal: a contract that makes leaving cost more than staying. Watch for these before you sign.

Clause or setupWhy it traps youAsk for instead
Agency registers your domainWhoever is listed as registrant controls the name and its transfer (ICANN)Domain in your business's name, your login
Agency is primary owner of your Google Business ProfileA profile has "only one primary owner"; owners add or remove users, managers can't (Google)You as primary owner; agency as manager
"Website included" with the planCancel the plan and the site may stay with themThe site and its files assigned to you once paid
12–24 month term, early-exit fee equal to the remaining monthsYou pay even if nothing improvesMonth to month, or 3–6 months, then 30 days' notice
Silent auto-renewalThe term restarts unless you cancel in a narrow windowRenewal only by written agreement
No list of work, only "SEO services"You can't tell if anything was doneA monthly log of changes and a report

The full clause list is in marketing agency contract terms. Already locked in? Leaving your marketing agency shows how to take back each account first.

Already caught in an SEO scam?

  1. Stop the money. Cancel in writing, and ask your bank or card issuer what it can stop or dispute.
  2. Take back the keys. Get yourself owner on your domain, Business Profile, Search Console and Analytics, then remove the old agency.
  3. Check for damage. Look in Search Console for a manual action and for links you didn't build.
  4. Keep the evidence. Emails, contracts, invoices and screenshots, with dates.
  5. Report it. In the US, Google points to the FTC (online or 1-877-FTC-HELP), and to econsumer.gov for companies abroad (Google Search Central: Do you need an SEO?). In Canada, the Canadian Anti-Fraud Centre takes reports online or at 1-888-495-8501 (CAFC).

Example

Illustrative cases. Figures are invented for the example.

A cleaning company gets a "47 errors" email

The sender has a Gmail address and offers a fix for $299. The owner opens Search Console: 38 of 40 pages indexed, no manual action. She deletes the email.

An electrician gets a $189 "SEO renewal"

It's marked past due, from a company nobody in the office recognizes. The bookkeeper finds no matching vendor or order, searches the name with "scam," finds complaints, and doesn't pay.

A landscaper tries to leave after a year

His $900-a-month contract runs 24 months, the agency owns his domain, and leaving costs the 12 remaining months. He pays the fee, gets the domain moved into his name, and signs his next deal month to month, with every account his.

FAQ

Is every unsolicited SEO email a scam?

Not every one, but Google tells owners to be wary of all of them. A real firm can show named clients you can call and won't ask for payment before you've checked.

Can an SEO company get my site banned from Google?

It can get your site ranked lower or dropped for spam, and Google holds you responsible for what you hire them to do. A manual action can be fixed and reviewed; see Google manual action.

Are SEO companies that call saying they're from Google real?

Treat them as scams. Hang up, sign in to your Business Profile yourself, and look for any notice. More in hiring an SEO company.

Should I pay someone who promises to remove bad reviews?

No. Google says paying doesn't guarantee removal and encourages more attempts. Report extortion through Google's merchant extortion form instead.

Is a long SEO contract always a bad sign?

Not always, but a long term with a large exit fee shifts all the risk to you. Ask for a short first term, so the agency earns the renewal.

Different for you?

Keep learning

NextMarketing agency contract: the terms to check before you signThe marketing agency contract clauses that decide who owns your accounts and website, what you see of ad spend, and how easily you can leave. US and Canada.

Ask us one question

One line is enough. We reply by email.

Sources

  1. Google Search Central: Do you need an SEO?
  2. Search Console Help: Disavow links to your site
  3. Google Business Profile Help: Report negative review extortion scams on your Business Profile
  4. Google Business Profile Help: Manage your Business Profile owners & managers
  5. ICANN: FAQs for Registrants: Transferring Your Domain Name
  6. FTC Consumer Alert: Run a small business? Pay your bills, not scammers (May 14, 2026)
  7. Canadian Anti-Fraud Centre: False billing
  8. Canadian Anti-Fraud Centre: Report fraud and cybercrime