SEO contractor not delivering? What to check before you leave
Short answer Before you fire an SEO contractor, check five things: whether enough time has passed, whether a Google update, season or site change explains the drop, what work they actually did, whether any of it breaks Google's rules, and whether a 90-day reset with clear numbers is worth trying. Leave at once only for rule-breaking or secrecy.
Want help applying this to your business? Talk it through on a free 30-minute call.
Book a callBefore you fire your SEO: five checks, in order
Most "SEO isn't working" moments are one of three things: too early, something outside the contractor's control, or a contractor who isn't doing the work. The checks below tell them apart in about an hour.
| # | Check | Where | If yes |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Has the work had time to show? | Your contract start date, their change log | Under 3 months: likely too early to judge |
| 2 | Does something else explain the drop? | Google Search Status Dashboard, Search Console, last year's numbers | Not their fault; ask for a plan |
| 3 | Can they show what they changed? | Ask for a dated list of changes | No list: a serious problem |
| 4 | Does any of it break Google's rules? | Their link reports, your site, Search Console's Manual Actions report | Leave, and undo the damage |
| 5 | Do you agree on what success means? | Your contract and monthly reports | No: reset before you judge |
Do checks 1 to 4 from your own logins, not from the contractor's screenshots. If you don't have owner access to Search Console and your Google Business Profile, get it first: see leaving your marketing agency.
Has it been long enough?
Judge a single change after a few weeks, and a provider after several months. Google's own timeline:
"Some changes might take effect in a few hours, others could take several months. In general, you likely want to wait a few weeks to assess whether your work had beneficial effects in Google Search results." (Google SEO Starter Guide)
Time alone proves nothing, though. By month three you should see leading signs: more clicks on searches that don't include your business name, and pages that moved up even if they aren't on page one yet. If nothing moved at all after six months, waiting longer rarely fixes it. For a brand-new site the clock runs slower: see how long SEO takes.
Is it the contractor, or something else?
Google's guide to debugging traffic drops lists the usual causes: an algorithm update, technical errors, security problems, spam issues, seasonality and changing interest, and site moves. Only some are the contractor's doing.
- A Google update. Check the Google Search Status Dashboard. As of November 16, 2026, the November 2026 core update is still rolling out; it started November 10. Google's core updates page says to wait "at least a full week after a core update completes" before analyzing your site. And its traffic-drop guide says of a drop after an update:
"there might not be anything fundamentally wrong with your content." (Google Search Central)
- The season. Compare with the same months last year. A roofer's February always looks bad next to October.
- Your own changes. A new website, a new booking page or new web addresses can drop traffic for weeks. Ask who made the change and whether the contractor was told. See traffic dropped after a redesign.
- Small moves. Going from position 2 to 4 can cut clicks without anything being broken. Google says such shifts "can happen at any time" and recommends "avoiding making radical changes if your page is already performing well."
If the drop matches an update or the season, the question for the contractor isn't "why did this happen" but "what's the plan now."
What did they actually do?
Ask for a dated list of every change: pages written or edited, technical fixes, Google Business Profile updates, links earned and from where. A good contractor has this already. Google suggests asking this before you hire anyone:
"Will you share with me all the changes you make to my site, and provide detailed information about your recommendations and the reasoning behind them?" (Google Search Central: Do you need an SEO?)
Then spot-check three items. Open the pages they say they wrote. Find the posts and updates they list on your Business Profile. If they list links, visit the sites. A report full of "audits" and "monitoring" with no changes you can see means you paid for watching, not work.
Red flags that mean leave now
Some problems don't deserve a 90-day reset, because the risk falls on you. Google is direct about who carries it:
"Ultimately, you are responsible for the actions of any companies you hire, so it's best to be sure you know exactly how they intend to "help" you." (Google Search Central: Do you need an SEO?)
| Red flag | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| Bought links, link packages, links from unrelated blogs | Google's spam policies list "Buying or selling links for ranking purposes" as link spam. Penalties hit your site, not theirs. |
| A manual action in Search Console | Google found a rule break. See Google manual action. |
| They won't say what they changed | Google: "Be careful if a company is secretive or won't clearly explain what they intend to do." |
| A guaranteed ranking | Google: "No one can guarantee a #1 ranking on Google." |
| Your site must link to them | Google: "You should never have to link to an SEO." |
| They own your accounts | You can't leave cleanly. Get ownership back before you give notice. |
The talk to have before you leave
If checks 1 to 4 come out fine but results still disappoint, the usual cause is that you and the contractor never agreed on what success looks like. Fix that in one meeting.
- Pick three numbers. Calls, forms and bookings from Google search and Maps; clicks on searches without your business name; and Business Profile calls. Rankings come last. See is my SEO working.
- Ask for a 90-day plan. Which pages, which searches, which fixes, in what order, and what number should move by when.
- Set the rhythm. One report a month with those three numbers, the list of changes, and one decision for next month. Google suggests asking any SEO "How can I expect to communicate with you?"
- Write down the exit. Check your notice period and what happens to content and accounts. See marketing agency contract terms.
Stay, reset or leave
| What you found | Decision |
|---|---|
| Under 3 months, work is visible, early signs moving | Stay |
| Drop matches a Google update or the season, and they have a plan | Stay and watch the next 2 months |
| Work is real but aimed at the wrong searches or numbers | Reset with a 90-day plan |
| 90-day reset done, the three numbers flat | Leave |
| No change list, bought links, secrecy, a guarantee | Leave now |
If you feel deceived
Google's "Do you need an SEO?" page points US complaints to the Federal Trade Commission, and complaints about a company outside the US to econsumer.gov. In Canada, the Competition Bureau takes complaints about representations that are "false or misleading in a material respect," through a form on its site. Neither will get your money back for you; for that, your contract and local small-claims court are the route.
Example
Illustrative cases with invented round numbers.
An HVAC company, month 4, US$1,200 a month
Traffic fell 25% in November. The dashboard shows a core update in progress, and last November fell 20% too. The change log lists 6 new service pages and 14 profile posts, all visible. Decision: stay, recheck a week after the update finishes.
A law firm, month 7, C$2,500 a month
Reports show rankings for the firm's own name and "SEO health score 92". No change list after two requests. Search Console shows 30 new links from unrelated blogs. Decision: leave now, take back owner access first, and ask the next provider to review the links.
A cleaning company, month 6
Work is real: 10 blog posts. But all target general cleaning tips, and calls from search are flat. Decision: reset. The new 90-day plan moves effort to pages for each service and city they serve.
FAQ
How long should I give an SEO contractor?
Three months to see early signs, six to judge results. Google says a single change can take "several months" to show.
Can a bad SEO contractor hurt my website?
Yes. Google says deceptive content made on your behalf can get your site "removed entirely from Google's index", and you are responsible for what they do.
Should I fire my SEO because rankings dropped?
Not on rankings alone. Check for a Google update and the season first, then look at calls and bookings from search.
What should a monthly SEO report include?
The three numbers you agreed on, the list of changes made that month, and the plan for next month. Tool scores aren't results.
Different for you?
- You've decided to leave: take back your accounts first.
- Traffic fell right after an update: core update recovery.
- Choosing the next provider: hiring an SEO company or agency vs freelancer vs in-house.
- Not sure the fee was fair: what SEO costs.
- You'd rather have the work done and reported each month: SEO & GEO Agent.